Judges' retirement age raised to 75

Summary#

HJR 199 proposes an amendment to the Missouri Constitution, replacing Article V, Section 26. If voters approve it, most judges’ mandatory retirement age would rise from 70 to 75; the stated purpose is to change the retirement age of judges.

  • The change would apply to all judges except municipal judges, subject to exceptions in the Constitution’s schedule.
  • Judges could still retire earlier at an age allowed by law and participate in a retirement plan provided by law.
  • The existing provision allowing the Supreme Court, with a retired judge’s consent, to assign that judge as a senior judge or special commissioner would remain. A senior judge would have the same powers as an active judge.
  • The amendment would go to voters at the November 2026 general election or at a special election called by the governor. It is not law unless voters approve it.

What it means for you#

  • Judges: If approved, the mandatory retirement age would be 75 instead of 70, except for municipal judges and any exceptions in the schedule. The bill does not change the rule allowing earlier retirement where authorized by law.
  • Missouri voters: You would vote on whether to adopt the constitutional amendment.
  • People who use the courts: The bill does not directly change court procedures, the powers of active judges, or how people bring cases. It could mean some judges remain eligible to serve as active judges for longer; that is an inference, not a guaranteed outcome.

Money#

No cost information is in the available material.

  • The bill does not appropriate money or change retirement benefits, contribution amounts, taxes, or fees.
  • It refers to retirement plans provided by law but does not estimate any effect on those plans’ costs.

What is unclear#

  • The bill does not state when the amendment would take effect if voters approve it.
  • It does not explain how the change would apply to judges who are already 70 or older.
  • The schedule exceptions are referenced but not included in the supplied material, so their effect could not be checked.
  • The bill does not estimate how changing the retirement age might affect retirement-plan costs or the number of judges serving.

Case for#

  • A possible argument for the bill is that judges who remain able and willing to serve could continue in office for up to five more years before mandatory retirement.
  • Keeping experienced judges eligible to serve longer could help retain their knowledge. This is a possible effect, not a result the bill guarantees.
  • The bill keeps the option for a retired judge to serve as a senior judge or special commissioner with the judge’s consent.

Case against#

  • One concern is that raising the mandatory retirement age could reduce opportunities for new judges to take those positions sooner.
  • The bill raises the age but does not add a new fitness review or explain how a judge’s ability to serve would be assessed.
  • It is unclear how the change would affect judges near or past the current retirement age, and what effect it might have on retirement-plan costs.