Mandatory extended terms for prior offenses

Summary#

HB 3536 would repeal and replace Missouri’s law on extended prison terms for prior criminal conduct. Its visible change is to make a court’s duty to impose an extended term mandatory (“shall”) in specified cases, rather than discretionary (“may”); the bill’s goal is not stated separately. It is introduced and is not law.

  • A court would have to impose an extended term if one of the bill’s listed conditions applies: the person qualifies as a persistent or dangerous offender under the stated rules, or a sentencing enhancement based on prior guilt or prior criminal conduct applies.
  • The bill says a persistent or dangerous offender convicted of a class B, C, D, or E felony must be sentenced to the authorized term for an offense one class higher.
  • The bill defines a persistent offender as someone found guilty of two or more felonies committed at different times, or someone previously found guilty of a dangerous felony. It also sets out a separate definition of dangerous offender.
  • A prior offender or persistent misdemeanor offender is not, on that basis alone, covered by the bill’s mandatory extended-term triggers.

What it means for you#

  • People being sentenced: If a listed condition applies, the court would have to impose an extended term. For a qualifying persistent or dangerous offender convicted of a class B–E felony, the bill specifies an offense class one level higher. This does not mean every person with a prior conviction would receive an extended term.
  • Courts: The bill would limit sentencing discretion in cases that meet the mandatory conditions. It does not set out a new application, review, or appeal process.
  • Other members of the public: The bill does not change which conduct is a crime, create a fine or fee, or directly change a public service.
  • Current law: The current version of section 558.016 was not supplied, so I could not verify which of the other provisions in the bill already exist. The bill’s markup does show “may” being replaced with “shall.”

Money#

No cost information is in the available material.

  • The bill does not state a spending amount, staffing requirement, fee, fine, or estimate of the cost of any change in prison terms.

What is unclear#

  • The bill does not say how its mandatory rule would interact with overlapping or competing sentencing enhancements.
  • It uses the phrases “based on a prior finding of guilt” and “based on a prior criminal conduct” without defining their full scope.
  • The bill gives no start date or cost estimate.
  • Because the current text of section 558.016 was not supplied, it is unclear how much of the bill’s other wording changes current law.

Case for#

  • A possible argument for the bill is that, once the specified prior-conduct conditions are met, sentencing would be mandatory rather than left to a court’s discretion.
  • The bill groups several kinds of prior-conduct sentencing enhancements under a rule requiring an extended term when the stated conditions apply.
  • For qualifying persistent or dangerous offenders convicted of class B–E felonies, the bill states a clear class-based sentencing rule.

Case against#

  • One concern is that making an extended term mandatory removes a court’s discretion to choose a lower sentence in cases that meet the conditions.
  • The bill’s broad references to enhancement provisions may create uncertainty about how the mandatory rule applies when more than one enhancement could apply.
  • The available material does not show the likely effect on prison terms or public costs.