Automated expungement and death penalty rules

Summary#

SB-1807 would replace Missouri law on sentencing for first-degree murder and add rules for automated expungement, credit reporting, and related funding. The bill’s stated goal is not given in the supplied text. It is introduced and is not law.

  • The Missouri State Highway Patrol would identify eligible records and send them through a process for court-ordered expungement (closing records so the public generally cannot access them). Courts, prosecutors, and other agencies would have set deadlines and duties.
  • Eligibility would generally require a one-year wait for misdemeanors or a three-year wait for felonies, with no new Missouri criminal conviction during that period. Lifetime limits and exclusions would apply.
  • Expungement would not erase all records or prevent all future use: specified justice agencies could access nonpublic records for listed purposes, and restitution owed to a victim would remain payable.
  • Courts and probation or parole offices would have to give eligible people information about the expungement program. Beginning in 2031, state offices would report statistics on eligibility, objections, and orders.
  • For first-degree murder cases, the bill would require a unanimous finding that aggravating circumstances outweigh mitigating circumstances before death can be imposed. If the jury cannot agree on punishment, the punishment would be life imprisonment without eligibility for parole, except by act of the governor.

What it means for you#

  • People with criminal records: Eligible electronic records could be expunged without a petition. The process would cover records from any date, but not juvenile records or specified offenses, including offenses under chapters 301–304 and 307. The bill also sets other eligibility rules, limits, and exceptions.
  • People whose records are expunged: The conviction would generally be treated as if you had not previously been convicted, but exceptions remain. Expungement would not refund fines or costs already paid, cancel restitution, or prevent specified justice agencies from using retained records. Some applicants for jobs at federally insured financial institutions or insurance businesses would still have to disclose expunged offenses.
  • Prosecutors, courts, and state agencies: The Highway Patrol would identify records and notify prosecutors. Prosecutors would have 60 days to object for listed reasons, including unpaid victim restitution or certain pending or out-of-state cases. Courts and agencies would then have deadlines to process orders and close records.
  • Credit bureaus and users of information: The bill would set limits on reporting criminal records and provide remedies for violations. Employers, volunteer organizations, and landlords would receive immunity from certain claims tied to misconduct related to an expunged record.
  • People facing first-degree murder charges: The bill would change the decision rules for imposing the death penalty. It would not change the stated rule that a person found intellectually disabled receives life imprisonment without parole, except by act of the governor.

Money#

The bill creates a fund and allows spending from it only after the General Assembly appropriates money; no cost estimate is provided.

  • The fund could pay for technology, systems, services, and necessary personnel or contractors for expungement and record-closing work.
  • It could receive appropriations, gifts, donations, grants, and bequests. The bill does not set an appropriation amount or estimate staffing costs.

What is unclear#

  • The current versions of the laws being changed were not supplied, so I could not verify how much of the expungement process or other provisions already exist, or compare all changes with current law.
  • Eligibility depends in part on offenses listed in section 610.140, but that section was not supplied. The bill also does not define every term used to determine eligibility.
  • The bill sets deadlines but does not explain how agencies will resolve disputed records, notify individuals of decisions, or correct mistakes before an expungement. It does allow a court to reinstate a conviction that was improperly expunged.
  • The technology implementation date depends on when money is appropriated, or July 1, 2029, whichever is later. The bill does not say how much funding will be provided.
  • It is unclear how the process will handle differences between records held by state and out-of-state agencies.

Case for#

  • A possible argument for the bill is that eligible people would not have to file a petition to have records closed, and old records could be handled in bulk.
  • The waiting periods, offense exclusions, lifetime limits, and prosecutor objections are safeguards against expunging records that do not meet the bill’s rules.
  • Retaining restricted records for specified justice-system uses could allow public access to be limited without removing all access needed for listed purposes.
  • The information documents at sentencing and release could tell eligible people about the program.

Case against#

  • The process depends on accurate electronic records and timely work by several agencies. The bill does not provide a cost estimate or describe how errors will be prevented before records are closed.
  • The bill does not set out a clear way for a person to challenge an eligibility decision or an objection before expungement.
  • Expungement would not make records unavailable for all purposes, and people in some regulated job applications would still have to disclose an expunged offense. That may limit the practical effect for some people.
  • The bill would change the rules for imposing the death penalty, including requiring a unanimous finding that aggravating circumstances outweigh mitigating circumstances. This could make death sentences harder to impose; the bill does not explain the intended effect of that change.