Modular homes protected from zoning bans

Summary#

SB 1774, titled “Modifies provisions relating to manufactured housing,” would add a new section to Missouri’s Chapter 64. Its stated goal is fair and equitable zoning for modular and manufactured homes; the bill would limit some local zoning rules for those homes, but it is not yet law.

  • Local governments could not ban modular homes or qualifying manufactured homes in residential zones where other single-family homes are allowed, or impose several kinds of more restrictive rules on them.
  • A “qualified manufactured home” would have to meet conditions including being no more than five years old when installed, at least 900 square feet, and attached to a permanent foundation. It must also be at least 20 feet wide or two stories tall, face the street at its main entrance, and have a block-wall or similar masonry foundation enclosure.
  • The bill would allow local compatibility standards, but architectural standards could not be stricter than those for other single-family homes in the same zone. A standard could not apply to these homes unless it also applied to all new site-built single-family construction in that zone.
  • Local governments could still adopt reasonable health and safety rules that do not create undue burdens specific to these homes. The bill also preserves local authority to protect historic properties and districts, and private homeowners’ associations and landowners could still set additional restrictions.
  • A zoning rule that violates the new section would be void and unenforceable. If enacted, the emergency clause says the section would take effect upon passage and approval.

What it means for you#

  • Local governments: They would have to follow the new limits when adopting or enforcing zoning and land-use rules. They could not require special permits or variances for modular or qualifying manufactured homes when comparable site-built homes do not need them.
  • People seeking to place a home: The bill would limit some local barriers, but it would not guarantee that a particular home can be placed on every lot. The bill’s protections depend on the home type and, for a “qualified manufactured home,” the conditions listed above.
  • Owners of other manufactured homes: The ban on outright bans and special permits is written to cover “qualified manufactured homes.” One separate restriction on more restrictive requirements refers to “manufactured homes” without that qualifier.
  • Homeowners’ associations and private landowners: The bill says it does not limit their ability to set additional covenants or restrictions on private land.
  • Residents generally: The bill does not create a housing program, payment, or new front-line service.

Money#

No publicly available information on costs is included in the supplied material.

  • The bill does not state a public spending amount, staffing requirement, fee, tax, or fine.
  • Local governments may need to change rules that conflict with the bill, but the material gives no estimate of that cost.

What is unclear#

  • The bill uses terms such as “undue burdens,” “reasonable” health and safety regulations, and “compatibility standards” without fully defining how they would apply.
  • It does not set out a process for handling complaints, deciding disputes, or enforcing the limits beyond making violating rules void and unenforceable.
  • The bill refers to installation under section 700.653, but that section was not supplied, so its requirements could not be checked.
  • The bill adds a new section rather than supplying existing zoning law for comparison. The available material does not show how the new limits would interact with all current state and local rules.
  • The bill is listed as introduced and referred to a Senate committee, so passage is uncertain. Its emergency start date would apply only if it becomes law.

Case for#

  • The bill appears intended to prevent local rules from excluding certain modular and manufactured homes where other single-family housing is allowed.
  • Requiring comparable treatment for these homes and site-built homes could reduce rules that single out factory-built housing.
  • Allowing health and safety rules, historic protections, and generally applicable zoning standards leaves local governments some authority to address those concerns.

Case against#

  • The bill’s eligibility conditions exclude manufactured homes that do not meet its age, size, height, foundation, or other requirements.
  • The terms governing health and safety rules and compatibility standards may leave uncertainty for local governments and residents about which restrictions are allowed.
  • The bill does not explain how disputes would be handled or how residents could challenge a local rule.
  • The limits on local zoning do not override restrictions set by homeowners’ associations or private landowners, so they may not remove all barriers to placing a home.