Lobbying disclosures tied to federal funds

Summary#

HB 938 would have added a disclosure rule to Montana’s lobbying law and amended the existing Lobbying Act in Title 5, chapter 7. Its stated purpose appears to be checking whether lobbying for state or local agencies and nongovernmental organizations is paid for with federal money; that is a goal, not a guaranteed result. The bill failed, so it did not become law.

  • Before lobbying for a state or local government agency or a nongovernmental organization, a lobbyist would have had to file an under-oath disclosure saying whether the client receives federal money.
  • The lobbyist would also have had to verify under oath that their compensation was not derived from federal money. The verification would need to be supported by an under-oath disclosure tracing the client’s receipt and use of federal money.
  • The lobbyist would have had to pay a $10 filing fee. The bill does not say whether the fee applies once or for each client or filing.
  • The bill would have added definitions of “federal money” and “nongovernmental organization” to the Lobbying Act. It also makes related changes to the numbering and cross-references of definitions.
  • A lobbyist who did not comply would face penalties already referred to in law. Knowingly filing a false, erroneous, or incomplete statement would be unsworn falsification.

What it means for you#

  • Lobbyists: They would have had to file the disclosures and pay the fee before lobbying for the covered clients. They could not lobby for those clients without the required verification and supporting disclosure.
  • State and local agencies and nongovernmental organizations: The bill does not directly require these organizations to file a disclosure or provide records. But a lobbyist’s required disclosure would have to trace the organization’s receipt and use of federal money.
  • Other lobbyists and the public: The new filing rule is limited to lobbying for the named types of clients. The bill does not directly change the public’s right to communicate with legislators.
  • Current law: The existing Lobbying Act is not included in the supplied material, so the exact difference from current definitions, filing rules, and penalties could not be verified.

Money#

The bill sets a $10 filing fee, but no estimate of public costs is available.

  • The fee would go to Montana’s general fund.
  • The bill does not estimate the cost of administering the disclosures or say whether extra staff would be needed.
  • It refers to existing penalties but does not state penalty amounts in the supplied text.

What is unclear#

  • “Compensation is not derived from federal money” and the required tracing of federal money are not explained in detail.
  • The bill gives no form, filing deadline beyond “prior to commencing services,” review process, or appeal process.
  • It is unclear how often a lobbyist would file or pay the fee when representing more than one covered client.
  • The bill does not say how a lobbyist could obtain the required information if a client does not provide it.
  • The current text of the amended Act was not supplied, so the existing rules and the exact effect of the definition changes could not be checked.

Case for#

  • The bill appears intended to make the source of lobbying compensation more visible when the client receives federal money.
  • Requiring a sworn disclosure and a trace of the client’s federal money could give the state information to check whether lobbying compensation came from that money.
  • A possible argument for a filing fee is that it would raise some revenue to the general fund.

Case against#

  • One concern is that the bill requires detailed sworn disclosures but does not explain what records are enough to trace an organization’s federal money or how to handle mixed funding.
  • The bill does not require the covered organization to provide information, yet the lobbyist’s ability to comply may depend on getting that information.
  • The filing and verification requirements could make it harder to begin lobbying for a covered client, even though the bill does not set out a review process or timeline.
  • The bill does not estimate the administrative cost or explain how the disclosures would be checked.

Votes

The recorded vote on this bill, member by member.

  1. Division No. 1532177

    Passed19 members voted

    (H) State Administration--To Table

    FOR · 18AGAINST · 1

    Each dot is one member. Hover or tap one to see who.

    18For

    • Democratic10
    • Republican8

    1Against

    • Republican1