Study rental laws and equity ownership

Summary#

HJ 41 was a proposed Montana joint resolution requesting an interim study; it failed and did not take effect. It would not have amended the Montana Residential Landlord and Tenant Act or the Montana Residential Mobile Home Lot Rental Act. Its stated goal was to identify outdated parts of those laws and possible areas for change.

  • It would have asked the Legislative Council to assign the study to an interim or statutory committee, or provide staff resources.
  • The study would review both laws, compare Montana’s rules with other states’ policies, and look at private equity firms’ ownership of housing in Montana and its possible effects.
  • The study would identify possible clarifications or reforms and seek feedback from renters, landlords, mobile-home residents and owners, tenant unions, landlord-tenant attorneys, and housing policy experts.
  • Any study and review would have been due before September 15, 2026, with results reported to the 70th Legislature. If staff conducted the study, a designated committee would review its findings or conclusions.

What it means for you#

  • Renters, landlords, and mobile-home residents or owners: The resolution would not have changed your rights, duties, rent, or rental agreements. It proposed studying the laws, not changing them.
  • Legislative Council and staff: If the resolution had taken effect, it would have requested that the Council arrange the study or assign staff resources. It did not set a budget or specify how much staff time to use.
  • General public: Because the resolution failed, it created no study assignment or new legal process.

Money#

No cost information is in the available material.

  • The proposed study could have used committee or staff resources, but the resolution gives no cost estimate or funding amount.
  • Because the resolution failed, it did not authorize spending for the study.

What is unclear#

  • The resolution does not say which committee or staff would conduct the study, or what methods they would use.
  • It does not define “private equity firms” or set criteria for measuring effects on affordability, housing stability, tenant protections, or community well-being.
  • It does not specify how feedback would be gathered or how the study would weigh different views.
  • The current texts of the two Acts were not provided, so their existing rules cannot be checked here.

Case for#

  • A study could give lawmakers a chance to examine whether two long-standing rental laws still fit current conditions before considering changes.
  • Comparing other states’ policies could help identify options for Montana; the resolution did not require the state to adopt any of them.
  • Seeking feedback from renters, landlords, mobile-home communities, and legal and policy experts could bring different perspectives into the review.

Case against#

  • The study’s scope is broad, but the resolution does not set detailed research methods or standards for judging whether a law is outdated.
  • It asks for an examination of private equity ownership and possible effects without defining the subject or how those effects would be measured.
  • A possible trade-off is using legislative staff or committee time for a study without specifying its expected cost or the resources available.

Votes

The recorded vote on this bill, member by member.

  1. Division No. 1551660

    Passed20 members voted

    (H) Judiciary--To Table

    FOR · 12AGAINST · 8

    Each dot is one member. Hover or tap one to see who.

    12For

    • Republican12

    8Against

    • Democratic8