Review of state procurement practices

Summary#

House Joint Resolution 42 (HJ 42) is an enacted Montana joint resolution requesting an interim study of state agency procurement. It asks the Legislative Council to assign a committee or staff to examine procurement practices and requires the study’s final results to be reported to the 70th Legislature. Its stated goal is to support responsible, consistent, and transparent use of public funds.

  • The study is to review state procurement statutes and rules, and identify how agencies decide whether to use standard procurement procedures or seek bids or proposals.
  • It is to examine a sample of contracts from each state agency from the past four years, with the sample kept to an amount not unduly burdensome to agency staff.
  • It is to account for payments to vendors selected outside the standard process and check contracts that departed from standard processes for signs of waste, fraud, or abuse.
  • It is to consider ways to standardize and centralize contract reporting, and recommend changes to statutes, rules, or agency procedures.
  • The study must include input from appropriate stakeholders and finish, including its presentation and review, before September 15, 2026.

What it means for you#

  • Montana residents: The resolution starts a study, not a new procurement rule or public service. It does not itself ban no-bid purchases, change who can receive a contract, or require contracts to be cancelled.
  • State agencies: The study is to sample procurement contracts from all agencies. The resolution does not set a specific sample size or say agencies must change their procurement practices.
  • Legislative Council and the committee or staff assigned: They are asked to carry out the study and report its results to the 70th Legislature. The resolution does not create a new independent agency.
  • Vendors: The resolution does not change vendors’ rights or duties under procurement contracts.

Money#

No publicly available information on the study’s estimated cost.

  • The resolution asks the Legislative Council to designate a committee or direct sufficient staff resources. It gives no staffing estimate or cost figure and does not state an appropriation.
  • The study is to account for money paid to vendors selected outside standard procurement processes; this is an accounting task, not a new payment or fee.

What is unclear#

  • The resolution does not set the sample size or explain how contracts will be chosen.
  • It does not define “standard procurement process” or say what counts as a deviation for the study.
  • It does not specify how the study will obtain records or how agencies or vendors will take part, beyond requiring input from appropriate stakeholders.
  • The resolution does not require particular changes after the study or set out enforcement for procurement violations.
  • The Montana Procurement Act and related rules are not included in the supplied material, so the current legal requirements and how much the study would add to existing oversight could not be verified.

Case for#

  • The study could give lawmakers a clearer picture of how agencies decide whether to seek bids or proposals and what obstacles affect procurement.
  • Reviewing a sample across all agencies could help identify whether departures from standard processes are isolated or point to broader problems.
  • Accounting for payments and considering centralized contract reporting could help lawmakers assess transparency and the use of public funds.
  • The study is directed to produce recommendations, allowing lawmakers to consider changes based on its findings.

Case against#

  • A sample, rather than a review of every contract, may not identify all departures or problems.
  • The resolution does not specify the sample size, selection method, or how the study will assess possible waste, fraud, or abuse.
  • It requires recommendations, but does not require the Legislature or agencies to adopt them.
  • The study requires staff resources, but the resolution gives no estimate of the time or cost involved.

Votes

3 recorded votes on this bill, newest first.

  1. Division No. 1556315

    Passed99 members voted

    (H) 3rd Reading Passed

    FOR · 70AGAINST · 29

    70For

    • Democratic39
    • Republican31

    29Against

    • Republican28
    • Democratic1

    1 member was paired and sat out the vote.

  2. Division No. 1553734

    Passed99 members voted

    (H) 2nd Reading Passed

    FOR · 76AGAINST · 23

    76For

    • Democratic39
    • Republican37

    23Against

    • Republican22
    • Democratic1

    1 member was paired and sat out the vote.

  3. Division No. 1539342

    Passed19 members voted

    (H) State Administration--Do Pass As Amended

    FOR · 18AGAINST · 1

    Each dot is one member. Hover or tap one to see who.

    18For

    • Democratic9
    • Republican9

    1Against

    • Democratic1