Judicial selection study would probe transparency

Summary#

HJ 64, “Study election and evaluation of judges,” was a House joint resolution, not a bill changing election law. It failed, so it did not create a study or change how Montana selects judges. Its stated goal was to examine ways to increase transparency and inform the public about judges and judicial candidates.

  • If adopted, it would have asked the Legislative Council to assign an interim or statutory committee to study judicial selection and evaluation.
  • The committee would have compared selection methods, judicial evaluations, and possible informational forums for all candidates for judicial office. The resolution did not require that any forums be held.
  • The study would have involved input from retired judges and justices, the Governor’s office, attorneys and others involved in court proceedings, and the public.
  • The study was to finish before September 15, 2026, with its results reported to the 70th Legislature.

What it means for you#

  • Montana voters and the public: No change to voting or judicial selection took effect. If adopted, the resolution would have included the public in the study, but it did not set out how people could give input.
  • Judges, candidates, and people involved in court proceedings: No new evaluation or candidate-information process was created.
  • State government: The resolution would have asked the Legislative Council to assign a committee to do the study. It did not itself change the law or constitution.

Money#

No publicly available information on the study’s cost or funding is included in the supplied materials.

  • The resolution did not state a budget, authorize a specific amount of spending, or say how many staff would be needed.

What is unclear#

  • The resolution did not name the committee that would conduct the study.
  • It did not define “transparency” or “judicial evaluations,” or set standards for comparing selection methods.
  • It did not explain how public input would be gathered or how the study would be staffed and funded.
  • It did not propose a specific change to judicial selection or evaluation; those details would have been for the study to consider.

Case for#

  • The resolution points to past legislative discussion and testimony about judicial selection, and calls for a more thorough comparison of options.
  • A study could let lawmakers examine methods used elsewhere and consider new ideas before deciding whether legal or constitutional changes are warranted.
  • Including the public and people with experience in the courts could bring different views into that review.

Case against#

  • The resolution set no criteria for evaluating the options, so the study’s scope and conclusions could depend on the committee’s choices.
  • It did not specify how public input would work or how much staff time and public money the study might require.
  • The resolution would study possible changes but did not identify a specific problem or propose a particular remedy.

Votes

The recorded vote on this bill, member by member.

  1. Division No. 1553315

    Passed19 members voted

    (H) State Administration--To Table

    FOR · 19

    Each dot is one member. Hover or tap one to see who.

    19For

    • Democratic10
    • Republican9

    0Against