Study to examine expungement barriers

Summary#

Montana House Joint Resolution 45 (HJ 45) is an enacted joint resolution requesting an interim study; it does not amend an existing law or change expungement rules. Its stated goal is to examine the barriers people with criminal records may face, including after their records are expunged.

  • It requests that the Legislative Council assign an interim or statutory committee to review Montana’s expungement laws and investigate the effects of criminal records and stigma.
  • The study is to cover topics including housing and employment barriers, discrimination, out-of-state issues, and commercial background-check providers.
  • The committee is asked to examine other states’ laws, peer-support models, and employment and housing outcomes. It is also asked to suggest possible changes to Montana law.
  • The resolution calls for the study to be completed before September 15, 2026, and its results reported to the 70th Legislature in the form of introduced legislation.

What it means for you#

  • People with criminal records: This resolution does not itself expunge records, change who qualifies for expungement, or create a new service. It calls for study of barriers affecting people with expunged records.
  • Employers, landlords and housing providers: It creates no new duties or penalties for you. The study may examine how you interpret expunged records and whether inquiries or decisions based on them create barriers.
  • State agencies and other named groups: The assigned committee is asked to work with the public and relevant state and national groups, including the Department of Justice, the Office of the State Public Defender, the Department of Corrections, county prosecutors and victim advocates.
  • The public and lawmakers: The committee’s report may propose legal changes, but HJ 45 does not require the Legislature to pass any proposed legislation.

Money#

No publicly available information on the study’s estimated cost.

  • The resolution does not state a funding amount or provide a cost estimate.
  • It does not set up a new program or provide funding for expungement services.

What is unclear#

  • The resolution requests that the Legislative Council designate a committee; the supplied text does not identify which committee will do the study.
  • The resolution does not set out the study’s methods, data sources, or how people with expunged records will be involved.
  • It asks the committee to explore possible incentive models, including Medicaid value-based payment models, for housing that is friendly to expungement. It does not establish such an incentive or explain how it would work.
  • The report must be submitted as introduced legislation, but the resolution does not say what proposals the committee will make or whether any will become law.

Case for#

  • A possible argument for the study is that it could clarify whether state laws create barriers based on criminal history even after a record is expunged.
  • It asks the committee to examine both legal barriers and practical problems, such as inaccurate information from commercial record providers.
  • Studying outcomes before and after expungement, and comparing other states’ approaches, could give lawmakers information to consider before changing state law.
  • The requested work includes input from public agencies, prosecutors, victim advocates and the public.

Case against#

  • One concern is that a study does not itself remove barriers or correct inaccurate records; any legal changes would require further action.
  • The resolution covers many topics, but does not specify research methods, data access or how the committee should weigh different findings.
  • It is unclear what resources the study will need, since no cost estimate or funding amount is given.
  • The resolution asks the committee to consider or explore some topics, so the text does not ensure that every proposed topic will receive the same level of attention.

Votes

3 recorded votes on this bill, newest first.

  1. Division No. 1552288

    Passed98 members voted

    (H) 3rd Reading Passed

    FOR · 95AGAINST · 3

    95For

    • Republican57
    • Democratic38

    3Against

    • Republican3

    2 members were paired and sat out the vote.

  2. Division No. 1551229

    Passed99 members voted

    (H) 2nd Reading Passed

    FOR · 94AGAINST · 5

    94For

    • Republican54
    • Democratic40

    5Against

    • Republican5

    1 member was paired and sat out the vote.

  3. Division No. 1548249

    Passed20 members voted

    (H) Judiciary--Resolution Adopted

    FOR · 20

    Each dot is one member. Hover or tap one to see who.

    20For

    • Republican12
    • Democratic8

    0Against