Autism data privacy rules would tighten data use

Summary#

AB-589, titled “Establishes requirements to protect the privacy of certain information and genetic material,” would have added new privacy rules to Nevada law and amended existing genetic-information laws. Its stated goal was to protect autism-related data and genetic information and samples; it was vetoed and did not become law.

  • State and local governments, and their contractors and grantees, would generally have been barred from collecting personally identifiable information showing that someone has or may have an autism spectrum disorder. The bill listed exceptions for benefits and services, education-program audits and legal compliance.
  • Those governments and contractors or grantees would generally have been barred from disclosing autism-related data outside the relevant agency or government. Exceptions included informed written consent, a court order or subpoena, providing services or supports, and complying with law. Disclosures would have had to use the minimum data needed—and omit the person’s name if de-identified data would serve the purpose.
  • The Governor’s Office would have had to review compliance by the Executive Department and its contractors and grantees every two years. The Health and Human Services Director could appoint time-limited advisory groups.
  • The bill would have expanded existing genetic-information rules to cover information from tests that derive and interpret data about a person’s genetic characteristics, and DNA samples (specimens from which DNA can be extracted, or extracted DNA itself).
  • It would have made certain unauthorized transfers of DNA samples or genetic information a category D felony, and certain unauthorized disclosures or genetic testing a category E felony. It also would have allowed a civil action for injury from violations involving disclosure or testing.

What it means for you#

  • Everyone: Because the Governor vetoed the bill, these proposed rules did not take effect.
  • People with autism, or suspected of having autism: If enacted, the bill would have limited when state and local governments and their contractors or grantees could collect or disclose personally identifiable autism-related data. It would not have barred all collection or sharing; the bill listed specific exceptions.
  • State and local governments, contractors and grantees: They would have had to follow the collection and disclosure limits. Autism-related data in their possession would not have been a public record under the proposed change. The Governor’s Office review duty covered the Executive Department and its contractors and grantees, not local governments.
  • People whose genetic information or DNA samples are held or tested: The bill would have extended consent-based restrictions to a broader range of genetic tests and to DNA samples. Exceptions included criminal or death investigations and proceedings, parentage or paternity determinations, court orders, some law-enforcement identification, infant screening, and specified medical, criminal-justice and federal-law circumstances.
  • People asked to join an advisory group: The Director could have appointed groups of 5 to 13 people from listed categories, including people with autism or family members, privacy experts and disability-rights attorneys. Members would have served without compensation; government employees on a group would have kept regular pay while doing its work.

Money#

No publicly available information on estimated costs or savings is included in the supplied material.

  • The bill required the Governor’s Office to conduct biennial reviews, but gave no cost estimate or staffing figure.
  • The Health and Human Services Director could appoint advisory groups. Members would receive no compensation, but government employees serving on them would keep their regular pay while carrying out group duties.
  • The State Board of Health would have had to adopt informed-consent procedures and forms unless federal law or regulation already required a procedure. No cost estimate is provided.

What is unclear#

  • The supplied material gives a summary of some existing genetic-information rules, but not the full current laws. I could not verify all changes against the complete current law.
  • The bill does not set out detailed procedures, timelines, appeal rights or penalties for violations of the autism-data rules.
  • It does not explain how the biennial reviews would be carried out or reported.
  • The Board of Health’s consent rules and forms were left for regulations. The bill does not give a deadline for those regulations.
  • The bill’s exceptions allow some collection, disclosure, testing or transfer without consent. How those exceptions would apply in particular cases is not resolved in the bill text.

Case for#

  • The bill appears intended to limit unnecessary collection and sharing of personally identifiable information about autism, while allowing it when needed for benefits, care, supports, education oversight or legal compliance.
  • Requiring the minimum necessary data, and avoiding a person’s name when de-identified data would work, could reduce exposure of sensitive information.
  • Expanding genetic privacy rules to cover DNA samples and a wider range of genetic tests could address information and material that the existing rules, as described in the bill’s digest, did not cover as broadly.
  • The listed exceptions preserve uses for criminal investigations, parentage determinations, medical purposes and other specified needs.

Case against#

  • The bill does not define how terms such as “necessary” would be applied to autism-data collection or disclosure. That could leave agencies and contractors uncertain about the limits.
  • It creates broad exceptions to genetic consent rules for specified legal, law-enforcement and medical purposes. The bill does not explain how those exceptions would be overseen.
  • The bill adds felony penalties and a civil claim but does not provide details in the supplied material about how violations would be detected or investigated.
  • The reviews, consent regulations and possible advisory groups would require government work, but the bill provides no cost estimate or staffing plan.

Votes

The recorded vote on this bill, member by member.

  1. Division No. 1578347

    Passed41 members voted

    Assembly Final Passage

    FOR · 27AGAINST · 14

    Each dot is one member. Hover or tap one to see who.

    27For

    • Democratic27

    14Against

    • Republican14

    1 member was paired and sat out the vote.