Scholarship program reporting and grant rules

Summary#

AB 599 would have amended Nevada’s existing laws for the Nevada Educational Choice Scholarship Program and added new requirements for scholarship organizations and participating schools. Its stated goal was to revise how the program is run and reported on; that goal is not a guaranteed result. The bill failed, so these proposed changes did not take effect.

  • Scholarship organizations would have had to register with the Department of Education and meet added requirements, including submitting financial statements and allowing officials to inspect records.
  • Organizations would have had to report grant and pupil information to the state. Schools receiving grants on behalf of pupils would have had to report pupils’ academic progress and disciplinary actions.
  • The bill would have set grant-award priorities: returning grant recipients first, then siblings of current recipients, then other applicants under rules based on application timing, household income and, in some cases, public-school ratings or a random selection.
  • Families could have applied directly to a registered organization. An organization could have charged up to $25 per family that applied.
  • The bill would have limited how long an organization could carry forward a donation to five years and raised the total annual tax-credit limit from $6.655 million to $8.725 million in fiscal year 2025–26 and $10.725 million in fiscal year 2026–27 and later years.

What it means for you#

  • Families applying for grants: The bill would have required organizations to use written, published application and award procedures and verify household income each year. A complete application would not guarantee a grant. The existing income limit—household income no more than 300% of the federal poverty level—would have remained.
  • Scholarship organizations: They would have had to register, submit required information and financial statements, report donations to the Department of Taxation, and make records available for inspection after notice. They also would have had to follow the grant priorities and could have charged families no more than $25 per application.
  • Schools receiving grants: They would have had to report each grant-funded pupil’s name, grade, academic information and disciplinary actions, and certify that the report was complete and accurate to the signer’s best knowledge or belief. The Department of Education could have suspended or disqualified a school for failing to report; organizations could not then send grants to that school.
  • Businesses paying the modified business tax: The bill would have increased the total tax credits the state could approve for donations to scholarship organizations. It would not have guaranteed that any one taxpayer received a credit.
  • General public: The bill would not have created a new independent agency, changed the program’s basic income limit, or required every eligible pupil to receive a grant.

Money#

The state fiscal note says the bill would affect the state but not local governments; it gives no cost estimate.

  • The higher tax-credit limits could reduce state tax revenue if credits were approved and used. The actual effect is not stated.
  • The Department of Education would have had new registration, reporting, data-analysis and oversight duties. No staffing or cost estimate is provided.
  • Scholarship organizations could have charged families up to $25 per family that applied. The bill does not estimate how often organizations would charge the fee.

What is unclear#

  • The supplied material does not include the full current law or regulations. It says some proposed requirements were already in regulations, but does not show exactly how the bill would change those rules.
  • The bill leaves details of applications and grant decisions to organizations’ written procedures and Department of Education regulations. It does not set an appeal process or deadlines for grant decisions.
  • It is unclear how the state would protect sensitive pupil information beyond requiring compliance with privacy laws and requiring the Department’s summary to be anonymized.
  • The bill does not explain how the five-year limit on carrying forward donations would affect funds not yet used for grants.
  • The bill specified a July 1, 2025 start date, but it failed and did not become law.

Case for#

  • The bill appears intended to make organizations’ eligibility, finances and grant decisions more visible to the state.
  • Requiring schools to report academic progress and discipline data could give the state information to assess the program’s effects.
  • The grant priorities could give returning recipients and their siblings priority before other applicants.
  • Raising the tax-credit ceiling could allow more donations to receive credits, if taxpayers and organizations used the available limit.

Case against#

  • The bill would have expanded the tax-credit ceiling, potentially reducing state revenue, without providing an estimate of the actual revenue effect.
  • Collecting pupil names, income and disciplinary information could create privacy risks; the bill does not set out detailed data-handling procedures.
  • Organizations would have had substantial responsibility for applications and awards, but the bill does not require a common decision process or appeals.
  • New reporting and inspection duties could add work for organizations, schools and the Department of Education, with no cost or staffing estimate.