Crackdown on staged crashes for insurance fraud

Summary#

AB-27, “Revises provisions relating to insurance fraud,” would amend Nevada’s insurance-fraud law. It would specifically include certain motor vehicle crashes arranged to support a false insurance claim and set higher penalties in specified cases; its stated purpose is to revise provisions on insurance fraud. The bill is prefiled and is not law.

  • A person who knowingly and willfully participates in, solicits or orchestrates a crash to support a false or fraudulent insurance claim would fall within the definition of insurance fraud.
  • Insurance fraud connected with such a crash would carry a category B felony penalty if benefits sought or obtained are at least $10,000, or if someone other than the perpetrator is injured.
  • In those cases, the prison term would be 2 to 15 years, with a possible fine of up to $50,000.
  • If the fraud causes substantial bodily harm or death, the prison term would be 5 to 20 years, with a possible fine of up to $100,000. The court must also order the person’s driver’s licence suspended or revoked for at least two years.
  • Other insurance fraud would remain a category D felony under the bill’s text.

What it means for you#

  • People who arrange or help arrange a crash for a false claim: The bill would explicitly treat that conduct as insurance fraud. The higher penalties depend on the amount of benefits sought or obtained and the harm caused.
  • People injured in such a crash: If the fraud causes bodily injury to someone other than the perpetrator, the higher 2-to-15-year penalty applies. If it causes substantial bodily harm or death, the more severe penalty and licence order apply.
  • Other drivers and insurance customers: The bill does not directly change insurance coverage, premiums, or the rules for making a legitimate claim.
  • Courts: For fraud causing substantial bodily harm or death, the court must order a licence suspension or revocation of at least two years. The bill does not specify which of those two options must be chosen.

Money#

The state fiscal note says the bill may have a fiscal impact, but gives no estimate.

  • Local government and the State Highway Fund are listed as having no fiscal effect.
  • The bill allows fines of up to $50,000 or $100,000 in the specified cases; it does not require a fine.
  • No information is provided about state costs, including possible prison costs.

What is unclear#

  • The bill does not define “substantial bodily harm.”
  • It does not set out how the state would investigate or prove that a crash was arranged for a false claim.
  • The supplied material does not show whether existing law already covers some crash-related fraud under its broader provisions. The bill would expressly name this conduct.
  • The bill would take effect upon passage and approval, but the prefiled bill has not yet passed.

Case for#

  • The bill appears intended to identify crash-related insurance fraud clearly in law, rather than leave it to broader fraud provisions.
  • Higher penalties tied to the value of benefits or injury may reflect the seriousness of the conduct and its consequences.
  • The strongest penalty applies when the fraud causes substantial bodily harm or death, linking a more severe sanction to serious harm.

Case against#

  • The bill does not explain how prosecutors would distinguish an arranged crash from a crash that was not staged but is followed by a false claim.
  • The bill sets substantial prison ranges and possible fines, but the supplied material does not explain why these penalty levels were chosen.
  • “Substantial bodily harm” is not defined in the bill text supplied, leaving a key trigger for the highest penalty unclear.