Trade rules rewrite for AI and groceries

Summary#

SB-31, “Revises provisions relating to trade practices,” would amend Nevada’s existing trade-practice laws in NRS Chapters 598 and 598A; it would not create a standalone agency or program. Its stated goal is to revise trade-practice rules, including rules for AI companions and grocery pricing. The bill is prefiled and is not law.

  • AI-companion operators would have to use self-harm detection and response protocols, tell users they are communicating with an automated system at specified times, and post information about the protocols online.
  • Operators would have to take additional steps for child users, including limits on certain outputs and on collecting, keeping, and sharing children’s personal information.
  • Grocery stores principally selling food for off-premises use, with more than 10,000 square feet open to the public, could not use protected-class data in specified ways or use defined surge or surveillance pricing. Stores would also have to clearly post prices for all goods.
  • Grocery stores could still offer price reductions uniformly or to customers who meet disclosed eligibility rules, provided the reductions do not violate the protected-class-data rule. Loyalty programs could continue under limits on how collected information is used.
  • Violations of the new AI and grocery provisions would be deceptive trade practices. The bill would also expressly treat an agreement between two or more grocery stores to use the same or commonly owned algorithm for surveillance pricing as price-fixing, and replace a civil-penalty limit based on a percentage of income with a limit of $50,000 per violation.

What it means for you#

  • People using AI companions: Operators would have to provide an automated-system notice at the start of each session, when a session resumes after an interruption of more than 15 minutes, and at least every two hours during a session. If the system detects self-harm or suicidal ideation, it must refer the user to a crisis service provider. Operators must also use reasonable measures to prevent content that encourages or instructs self-harm.
  • Children and their families: If a companion is directed to children, or the operator knows or reasonably should know a user is a child, it must use reasonable measures to prevent outputs that promote or facilitate listed harms, encourage secrecy or isolation, or involve specified sexual content. For users the operator knows or reasonably should know are children, it must limit personal information collection, retain it securely only as long as reasonably needed, and not share it with third parties except for age verification. Age-verification information has restricted uses.
  • Grocery shoppers: The bill would restrict certain individualized pricing practices at covered stores. It would not ban all discounts: uniform discounts and discounts for people meeting disclosed eligibility rules are allowed, subject to the protected-class-data rule.
  • Covered grocery stores and AI operators: They would face new requirements and could face enforcement under deceptive-trade-practice law. The bill does not set out a new application or approval process.

Money#

The bill’s fiscal note says it may affect state finances and may increase or newly provide for jail or detention costs for local government; it gives no estimate.

  • The bill sets a $50,000 maximum civil penalty for each violation of the specified provisions of NRS Chapter 598A, replacing a maximum tied to a percentage of certain in-state income. The materials do not show how the change would affect penalties in practice.
  • Operators and covered stores would have compliance duties, but no cost estimate is provided.
  • No appropriation or specific staffing amount is stated in the supplied text.

What is unclear#

  • The bill does not state when it would take effect.
  • “Reasonable methods” and “reasonable measures” are not given specific standards, and the bill does not set out investigation, appeal, or reporting procedures beyond the required online AI notice and its annual count of users referred to crisis services.
  • The bill uses broad terms such as “protected class data” and defines algorithms and pricing practices; how those definitions apply to particular pricing systems is not explained.
  • The supplied materials do not include the current text of NRS Chapters 598 and 598A. I could not verify which existing requirements or enforcement rules would overlap with these changes, or the full penalties that may apply to deceptive trade practices.
  • The bill does not explain how its new pricing rules would interact with other grocery-pricing programs.

Case for#

  • The bill appears intended to address risks when AI companions interact with users in personal or emotionally sensitive ways. Crisis referrals, self-harm safeguards, and clear notice that the system is automated could help users understand and respond to those interactions.
  • Stronger limits on outputs and personal-information practices for child users could reduce children’s exposure to harmful content and unnecessary data collection.
  • Posting grocery prices and restricting certain forms of individualized pricing could make prices more visible and limit pricing based on personal information or predicted willingness to pay.
  • Treating agreements to use a shared surveillance-pricing algorithm as price-fixing could make that specific form of coordination clearer under the state’s restraint-of-trade law.

Case against#

  • The rules depend in part on terms such as “reasonable measures” and on whether an operator should have known a user was a child. The bill does not give detailed standards for applying those tests.
  • The AI rules apply to systems meeting a multi-part definition, with several exclusions. Operators and users may not know in advance how a particular product will be classified.
  • The grocery rules could limit some price changes or discounts based on demand, behavior, or consumer data, including some discounts tied to protected-class data. The bill does not estimate the effects on stores or shoppers.
  • The bill adds enforcement consequences but does not provide a cost estimate or explain how the new rules would be coordinated with existing trade-practice protections.