Minister Could Make Child Protection Agreements

Summary#

The minister responsible for Social Development would be expressly allowed to make an agreement with a parent to protect a child or youth without returning them to that parent’s care. Bill 21, An Act to Amend the Child and Youth Well-Being Act, is at first reading and is not law.

  • The agreement could include custody or guardianship arrangements.
  • The bill would treat certain agreements made from January 26, 2024, until the Act starts as valid if the minister made them within five days after providing protective care interventions.
  • It would confirm related actions taken during that period and prevent certain challenges to the minister’s authority if the minister acted in good faith.

What it means for you#

  • Parents: The minister could make an agreement with you about your child’s care without returning your child to your care. The bill does not require you to enter an agreement.
  • Children and youth: The bill creates no direct right or service for you; it gives the minister authority to make these agreements with a parent.
  • Minister and government: Certain past agreements and actions would be treated as valid. A case questioning the minister’s authority to act could not be brought against the Crown or minister if the minister acted in good faith.

Money#

No publicly available information on cost.

What is unclear#

  • The bill does not define “protective care interventions” or set criteria for making an agreement.
  • It does not say how children and youth would participate or how an agreement could be reviewed. Whether other parts of the Act address these matters is unclear.
  • The bill adds express authority, but whether it overlaps with authority already in the Act is unclear.

Case for#

  • Agreements could let the minister and a parent arrange protections for a child without returning the child to the parent’s care. That gives them a way to address the child’s well-being while keeping the child out of that care.
  • Confirming past agreements and actions could give families and the government more certainty about arrangements made since January 2024. Keeping unexpired agreements valid could avoid disrupting those arrangements.

Case against#

  • The agreement power could leave children in arrangements made with a parent without the child’s own participation. The amendment sets no participation or review process, which could make it harder to address a child’s concerns.
  • The bill would validate past actions and limit challenges to the minister’s authority when the minister acted in good faith. That could make it harder to obtain a legal remedy for an action taken under authority that was uncertain at the time.