Summary#
Health care organizations would have to report patient safety incidents, review certain serious incidents, and plan and report yearly quality improvements. Bill 40, An Act Respecting Health Quality and Patient Safety, would amend New Brunswick’s Health Quality and Patient Safety Act and its regulation. The bill is at first reading, so it is not law and its passage is uncertain.
- Staff who discover an incident would have to report it as soon as circumstances permit. Organizations would have to review incidents involving multiple patients or meeting the bill’s definition of a critical event.
- Organizations would have to prepare yearly quality improvement plans and reports, carry out planned activities, follow standards and policies set by the Minister, and report certain risks to the Minister.
- The Minister would establish an advisory committee, made up of health care organization representatives and at least one patient, family member or caregiver. The committee would advise the Minister and review quality reports.
- Organizations would have to tell affected patients about incidents involving harm or an ongoing safety risk. Patients could request the incident report free of charge.
What it means for you#
- Patients: If an incident harms you or creates an ongoing safety risk, the organization would have to notify you and share available facts and information about care you need. If a quality review happens, it would also share the committee’s approved recommendations.
- Patients and families: You could ask the organization for the incident report without charge. The bill does not require organizations to notify patients about every incident.
- Health care organization staff: Staff who discover an incident would have to submit a report. The bill does not set a specific deadline beyond “as soon as the circumstances permit.”
- Health care organizations: They would have to conduct reviews for multiple-patient events and critical events, prepare plans and reports, and maintain an incident reporting system. They would also have to share specified information with the Minister and advisory committee.
- The public: Organizations could disclose some reports and performance information, but quality assurance and surveillance information would generally be confidential. The bill does not create a general public right to see incident records.
Money#
No publicly available information on the total cost.
- Organizations would have to provide staff time and systems for reporting, reviews, plans and data sharing; the bill gives no cost estimate.
- The Minister may approve funding for quality improvement activities and may withhold some or all of those payments if an organization is not complying.
- The bill does not set aside a specific amount for the new advisory committee or these duties.
What is unclear#
- Some changes may restate existing rules; the bill does not show how much would be new compared with current law.
- The bill leaves details of many requirements to regulations, standards or the Minister. It does not define “never event,” and it allows the Minister to set incident categories and data requirements.
- The Act says plans and reports go to the Minister, while the regulation says organizations submit them to the advisory committee. How those directions fit together is unclear.
- The bill gives no general start date. It sets April 1, 2027, for one regional health authority data-sharing duty and December 1, 2027, for another.
Case for#
- Mandatory reviews of critical and multiple-patient events would require organizations to examine serious risks rather than leave every review to their discretion. That could help identify causes affecting more than one patient and prompt changes to care.
- Yearly improvement plans, reports and standardized incident data would give organizations and the Minister a recurring way to track safety work. Comparing information across organizations could help direct attention to repeated problems.
- Required disclosure to affected patients, including access to the incident report, would give patients more information about what happened and what care they may need. Protecting apologies from being treated as admissions of fault could make it easier to express regret.
Case against#
- The bill gives the Minister broad power to require improvement activities, set standards and policies, and withhold funding payments for non-compliance. Organizations could face funding pressure based on requirements whose details the bill leaves to the Minister or regulations.
- Mandatory reviews, annual plans and reports, and data-sharing duties would take staff time and organizational resources. Without limits or details in the bill, organizations may have difficulty balancing this work against other care needs.
- Confidentiality rules and limits on using statements or evidence given under the Act could make some information harder to use in public scrutiny or legal proceedings. That may reduce the ability of patients or others to establish responsibility, even when the bill requires some disclosure.