Order Council Members Face New Rules

Summary#

Bill 8 would change a count from five individuals to ten and set tenure and removal rules for one category of Order council members. It amends New Brunswick’s Order of New Brunswick Act. It is a first-reading bill, so it is not law and may not pass.

  • The number in the Act’s rule about individuals would rise from five to ten; the bill does not identify what that number counts.
  • Members appointed under one specified category would stay in office until they resign or are reappointed or replaced.
  • The Executive Council could remove those members for cause, but only on the council’s recommendation.
  • The bill deletes a phrase saying something in another subsection is “as determined by the Executive Council”; the effect is unclear without that subsection’s full wording.

What it means for you#

  • People counted under the five-to-ten rule: The number would increase, but the bill does not say who these individuals are or what the count covers.
  • Order council members appointed under the specified category: They would remain in office until they resign or are reappointed or replaced. The Executive Council could remove them for cause on the council’s recommendation.
  • The Executive Council: It would have an express power to remove those members for cause, subject to the council’s recommendation.

Money#

No cost estimate is given; the bill does not set a payment, fee or appropriation.

  • The bill does not state whether the changes would affect staffing or other administrative costs.

What is unclear#

  • What the five-to-ten count applies to, and whether it is a limit or a different kind of count.
  • Who is included in the council-member category named in the bill.
  • What the deleted phrase changes in the full subsection, and what “for cause” means or what process would apply.
  • The bill gives no start date.

Case for#

  • Raising the count from five to ten could give the Order more capacity if the number is a limit on how many individuals may be included. That could allow more people to be recognized without changing the rest of the Act.
  • Keeping council members in office until they resign or are replaced could preserve continuity. The council would not necessarily lose a member simply because another term rule would otherwise end their appointment.

Case against#

  • If the five-to-ten count limits how many people can be recognized, doubling it could make that recognition less selective. The bill does not explain why that larger number is appropriate.
  • Keeping members in office until they resign or are replaced could delay turnover. Without a fixed end date in this rule, members could remain in their roles for an extended time.