911 Service Would Cover Full Response

Summary#

New Brunswick’s 911 service would be defined to cover coordination from receiving an emergency request until appropriate responders reach the scene, including reporting emergencies to service providers. First-reading Bill 9, An Act Respecting the Emergency 911 Act, would amend the Emergency 911 Act and its regulation; it would start on dates set by proclamation.

  • The regulation would name the Medical Communications Management Centre and the Provincial Mobile Communications Centre as secondary answering points for all areas of the province.
  • The minister could create advisory committees and set technology standards for answering points. If specified regulations have not been made, the minister could also establish operating arrangements, procedures, policies and services outside the Regulations Act.
  • The bill would let regulations set operating requirements for emergency service providers, require performance reports, and set security, continuity and incident-reporting rules.
  • Emergency service providers and their employees would have to share directly related information, including personal information, when necessary for the 911 service or their related duties. Unauthorized use or disclosure would be a category F offence.

What it means for you#

  • People who call 911: The bill describes the service as covering the process from receiving a request through responders reaching the emergency. It does not set response-time guarantees or create a new way to contact 911.
  • Answering points and emergency service providers: Future regulations could require technical standards, performance reports and security or incident reporting. The bill does not impose all those requirements immediately.
  • Emergency service staff: They would have to share relevant information when the bill’s necessity test is met, and could not otherwise use or disclose information obtained through their 911 duties, except as necessary for the service.

Money#

No publicly available information on the bill’s cost.

  • The bill sets no budget, fee or funding source.
  • It allows the minister to create advisory committees and establish standards and procedures, but does not state the staffing or implementation costs.

What is unclear#

  • Some changes may restate existing rules; it is unclear how much is new.
  • The bill does not define when information-sharing is “necessary” or what information “relates directly” to the service.
  • It does not set out detailed rules for access to, storage of or retention of shared information.
  • The bill does not give a start date; its provisions would begin on dates set by proclamation.

Case for#

  • Defining the service across the full chain of emergency response and naming secondary answering points across the province could give agencies a clearer shared picture of how calls move from answering to dispatch.
  • Giving the minister tools to set common security, continuity and incident-reporting rules could help address risks that cross agency boundaries, rather than leaving each provider to use a different approach.

Case against#

  • The bill allows the minister to establish broad operating rules outside the Regulations Act when specified regulations have not been made. That gives the minister substantial control over important service details without requiring the bill to set out a public consultation or review process.
  • Required information-sharing includes personal information, and the bill leaves key terms such as “necessary” undefined. Without more detail on access and handling, staff may apply the sharing rule differently and personal information may be disclosed more widely than intended.