Residential-ratepayer board expands oversight duties

Summary#

HB 610, “Relative to the residential ratepayers advisory board,” amends New Hampshire’s RSA 363:28-a by repealing and reenacting the section on the board. It changes the board’s composition and role in overseeing the Office of the Consumer Advocate. Its stated goal is to keep the Consumer Advocate focused on residential utility customers’ service, costs, and freedom of choice; that goal does not guarantee a particular result. The bill is signed into law and takes effect 90 days after passage.

  • The board has nine public members: three appointed by the House speaker, three by the Senate president, and three by the governor and council. The seats are assigned to represent residential ratepayers, older people, people with disabilities, environmental concerns, people with low incomes, small-business owners, residents of low-income housing, and the public.
  • The board must oversee the Office of the Consumer Advocate and ensure the Consumer Advocate focuses exclusively on residential customers’ safe, reliable service at the lowest possible cost while maximizing customer freedom and autonomy.
  • The board must meet at least quarterly. It advises the Consumer Advocate on residential-ratepayer matters, with an exception for certain end users and services of an “excepted local exchange carrier.”
  • The board must recommend whether to reappoint the Consumer Advocate. Under specified conditions, it must recommend three people to fill the position.
  • After notice and an opportunity for a hearing, a two-thirds board vote may recommend that the governor seek the Consumer Advocate’s removal for failure to carry out the powers, duties, and limits set by law.

What it means for you#

  • Residential utility customers: The board is directed to oversee the Consumer Advocate and advise that office on residential-ratepayer matters. The bill does not guarantee lower bills, a particular service level, or a particular outcome in a utility matter.
  • Consumer Advocate and office: The Consumer Advocate must attend board meetings, report on the office’s actions, and answer the board’s questions. The office must provide the board with administrative support.
  • Board members: Members serve three-year terms and receive no compensation, but are entitled to mileage reimbursement at the state-employee rate.
  • People who appoint or select the Consumer Advocate: The House speaker, Senate president, and governor and council appoint the board members for their designated seats. The governor and council receive the board’s recommendation on reappointment or, in specified circumstances, three names to fill the position.
  • General public: The act changes the board’s statutory role; it does not create a new independent agency or a direct customer service program.

Money#

The fiscal note estimates no impact on state, county, or local expenditures or revenue.

  • The board must receive administrative support from the Office of the Consumer Advocate, and members are entitled to mileage reimbursement. The bill provides no separate estimate for those costs.

What is unclear#

  • The supplied material does not include the prior text of RSA 363:28-a. It therefore does not show which detailed rules are new, beyond the stated changes to the board’s composition and objectives.
  • The bill does not set out procedures for the board’s oversight, such as how it will conduct inquiries or how the Consumer Advocate must respond to its advice.
  • The bill does not define “excepted local exchange carrier.”
  • The act takes effect 90 days after passage, but the supplied material does not give the passage date. Exact effective date: No publicly available information.

Case for#

  • A possible argument for the bill is that a board with seats assigned to several affected groups can give the Consumer Advocate a regular source of advice about residential customers’ interests.
  • Regular meetings, required attendance by the Consumer Advocate, and reports on the office’s actions could make its work more visible to the board.
  • The reappointment and removal recommendation processes give the board a formal way to raise concerns about whether the Consumer Advocate is carrying out the duties set by law.

Case against#

  • One concern is that the bill gives the board an oversight role without explaining how that oversight works or how its advice affects the Consumer Advocate’s decisions.
  • The board may recommend removal for failure to meet duties that include broad aims such as maximizing customer freedom and autonomy. The bill does not explain how such aims will be assessed.
  • The Consumer Advocate’s required exclusive focus may involve competing goals—such as low cost and reliable service—but the bill does not say how to weigh them when they conflict.