EV Makers Would Lose Direct Sales Exception

Summary#

A-5823 would end special permission for certain zero-emission-vehicle makers to sell directly to consumers; those makers would have two years to comply with franchise rules. The “New Jersey Franchised Automobile Industry Retail (FAIR) Sales Act” also bars motor-vehicle franchisors from operating galleries or studios, amending the state’s dealer-licensing law and the 1985 law governing motor-vehicle franchises.

  • Covered zero-emission-vehicle makers would have to sell through franchised dealers, as other manufacturers generally must.
  • Franchisors could not operate galleries or studios, including places that display vehicles or offer test drives without selling them.
  • A new-motor-vehicle dealer would need to be authorized by a franchisor, have an established business location, and sell at least four new vehicles in a 12-month period.
  • A qualifying maker’s existing service facility could continue operating if it was established before the bill takes effect and is not also a gallery or studio.

What it means for you#

  • Vehicle buyers: You could no longer buy directly from a maker covered by the repealed exception. You would have to buy through a franchised dealer. The bill does not ban buying those vehicles.
  • Covered zero-emission-vehicle makers: You would have two years from the bill’s effective date to comply with the franchise law. The bill takes effect immediately, so its gallery ban would start then.
  • Franchisors and gallery operators: A franchisor could not run a gallery or studio directly or through another person. The bill does not impose this ban on every vehicle-display business, regardless of its connection to a franchisor.
  • Vehicle service customers: A qualifying maker could keep a pre-existing service facility, including one doing warranty service, if it is not also operated as a gallery or studio.

Money#

The bill gives no public-cost estimate or appropriation; no publicly available information gives an estimate of its costs.

  • The bill does not specify the costs manufacturers or dealers may face when changing sales arrangements.
  • It does not specify a new tax, fee, or payment for consumers.

What is unclear#

  • The bill does not explain how a maker would establish franchise arrangements or what would count as compliance during the two-year transition.
  • It does not further define how regulators would distinguish a gallery or studio from a permitted service facility.
  • The bill has been introduced but is not law; whether it will pass is uncertain.

Case for#

  • Requiring covered makers to sell through franchised dealers puts them under the same basic sales arrangement as other manufacturers. That could protect dealers from competing against the manufacturers that supply them.
  • Barring galleries and studios closes a route for manufacturers to display or promote vehicles outside the franchise system. Keeping sales and vehicle displays within that system could make it clearer which businesses are responsible for customer service.

Case against#

  • Ending direct sales removes a way for customers to buy from covered manufacturers. Requiring a dealer between maker and buyer reduces consumer choice about how to purchase.
  • The gallery ban also covers places that only display vehicles or offer test drives. Customers could lose a way to see or try a vehicle without visiting a franchised dealer, even when the gallery does not complete sales.