Lottery deposits switch to net revenue

Summary#

SB-309, “Lottery Deposits Into Tuition Fund,” would amend New Mexico’s Lottery Act. It would change the monthly transfer from lottery revenue to the Lottery Tuition Fund; its stated goal is to set deposits by net revenue, with a return to gross-revenue deposits after two years below specified amounts. The bill was introduced and then postponed indefinitely, so it has not changed the law.

  • Under the text shown, the current rule requires the Lottery Authority to send at least 30% of the previous month’s gross revenue to the fund. The bill would instead require it to send, as nearly as practicable, that month’s net revenue.
  • If net-revenue deposits are below $43 million annually for two consecutive fiscal years in fiscal years 2027–2029, the Authority would have to return to monthly deposits of 30% of the previous month’s gross revenue.
  • From fiscal year 2030 onward, the same fallback would apply after two consecutive fiscal years below $45 million annually.
  • The State Treasurer would continue to receive the transfers and deposit them in the Lottery Tuition Fund.
  • The existing requirement that at least 50% of gross annual lottery revenue be returned as prizes would remain.

What it means for you#

  • Lottery Authority: It would have to calculate and transfer monthly net revenue instead of at least 30% of gross revenue, unless the bill’s two-year shortfall condition triggers the 30%-of-gross rule.
  • State Treasurer and Lottery Tuition Fund: The Treasurer would continue to deposit the transfers into the fund.
  • Lottery players: The bill does not change the stated minimum share of gross annual revenue returned as prizes.
  • Students and families: The bill does not change who qualifies for tuition assistance or how much assistance they receive.
  • General public: It does not create a new tax, fee, or lottery program.

Money#

No publicly available information on the bill’s implementation cost or its expected effect on fund deposits.

  • The bill would change how much lottery revenue is transferred, but does not guarantee an annual deposit of $43 million or $45 million. It does not require a top-up if deposits fall below those amounts.
  • The Lottery Authority would have to make monthly transfers. The bill gives no estimate of staffing or other administrative costs.

What is unclear#

  • The bill does not define “net revenue” or explain how it is calculated. It lists lottery operating expenses elsewhere in the section, but does not state how those expenses determine net revenue for this transfer.
  • “As nearly as practicable” does not specify how close a transfer must be to net revenue or what happens if the amount cannot be calculated or transferred as planned.
  • The fallback is triggered by deposits below the stated amount for two consecutive fiscal years; the bill does not explain how the trigger is applied if the shortfall spans the 2029–2030 change in thresholds.
  • The bill does not explain how this transfer rule interacts with other Lottery Tuition Fund rules. The parent Act was not supplied, so surrounding provisions and current implementation could not be checked.

Case for#

  • A possible argument for the bill is that basing monthly transfers on net revenue could account for lottery operating costs rather than requiring a set share of gross revenue.
  • The fallback would restore the 30%-of-gross rule after two consecutive years of deposits below the stated threshold, which could provide a safeguard for the fund.
  • Keeping the existing prize minimum would preserve the stated share of lottery revenue returned as prizes.

Case against#

  • One concern is that changing from at least 30% of gross revenue to net revenue could reduce transfers to the tuition fund.
  • The fallback does not start after one low-deposit year, and it does not require the Authority to make up a shortfall. The stated dollar amounts are therefore not guaranteed minimum deposits.
  • Because “net revenue” and “as nearly as practicable” are not defined, the bill leaves important parts of the monthly transfer calculation unclear.