Summary#
Introduction 0088-2026, sponsored by Council Member Gale A. Brewer, would amend the New York City Administrative Code. It would require the Department of Housing Preservation and Development (HPD) to report each year on sales of housing development fund company (HDFC) units. The stated goal is increased transparency; the bill is in committee and is not law.
- HPD would send the report to the Mayor and the Council Speaker.
- For the preceding calendar year, the report would give the number of HDFC units sold and their average and median sale prices, by district.
- The text sets the first deadline as June 1, 2023, and requires reports annually after that.
What it means for you#
- HPD: Would have to prepare and submit the annual report. The bill does not require HPD to publish it for the public.
- HDFC unit sellers and buyers: The bill does not change sale rules, prices, eligibility, or ownership. It requires reporting on sales, but does not create an application or review process.
- City residents: The report would go to the Mayor and Council Speaker, not directly to residents.
Money#
No publicly available information on the cost.
- The bill requires HPD to produce annual reports, but provides no cost estimate or staffing details.
What is unclear#
- The June 1, 2023 deadline is already past. The bill does not explain how HPD should handle that deadline if the bill becomes law later.
- The text first says “community board district,” then says “community district”; it does not clarify whether these mean the same reporting area.
- The report goes to two city officials, but the bill does not say whether or how it would become public.
- The bill uses the definition of HDFC in New York State’s Private Housing Finance Law. That law was not supplied, so the definition and how it applies cannot be verified here.
- The bill does not specify how HPD would collect or verify sale data.
Case for#
- A possible argument for the bill is that district-level counts and sale-price averages and medians could give city officials a clearer picture of HDFC unit sales.
- Annual reporting could make it possible to compare sales information across years.
Case against#
- The bill does not require public release, so residents may not be able to access the information directly.
- The first reporting deadline has passed, and the bill does not explain what HPD must do about it.
- The bill does not spell out how HPD would obtain or verify the information, or how much reporting would cost.