Studying and reporting on transportation impacts of decisions of the city planning commission in connection with certain land use actions

Summary#

Introduction 105-2026, sponsored by Council Member Selvena N. Brooks-Powers, would amend the New York City Charter. Its goal is to compare actual transportation conditions after certain large land-use actions with the impacts forecast in their environmental impact statements (EISs), and recommend changes to the city’s forecasting manual when specified gaps are found. It has only been introduced and referred to committee, where it is waiting; it is not law.

  • For covered actions certified on or after January 1, 2019, the Department of City Planning (DCP)—or the lead agency if the City Planning Commission was not the lead agency—must study transportation impacts in coordination with the Department of Transportation.
  • A covered action must involve at least four adjacent blocks and meet the bill’s approval requirements. Studies must examine conditions from final approval through four years and through ten years after approval.
  • Each study must compare actual conditions with the EIS’s projected impacts or lack of impacts, and assess whether promised mitigation offset impacts and when each measure was implemented.
  • Reports must go to the Mayor, Council Speaker, affected borough president, community board and Council Member, within six months after each study period ends. If a metric differs by more than 5%, or the study finds an impact the EIS did not discuss, the report must recommend changes to the CEQR Technical Manual and discuss whether a vehicle-miles-traveled model could improve forecasts.

What it means for you#

  • People in affected areas: The bill would require follow-up studies and reports about transportation conditions. It does not change land-use approvals, require new mitigation, or create a public application or appeal process.
  • City agencies: DCP, or the relevant lead agency, must conduct the studies and reports with DOT’s coordination. The specified local officials and bodies must receive the findings.
  • City Planning Commission and applicants: The bill does not change the approval process or impose a new duty on applicants.

Money#

No cost information is in the available material.

  • The bill requires agency studies, coordination and reports, but gives no staffing or cost estimate.

What is unclear#

  • The current Charter was not supplied, so it is not possible to verify what study or reporting duties already exist.
  • The bill does not specify how agencies must calculate each transportation metric or determine whether mitigation offset an impact.
  • It does not require the reports to be published for the general public.
  • The bill does not say how recommendations to change the CEQR Technical Manual would be considered or acted on.

Case for#

  • The bill appears intended to check whether transportation forecasts in EISs match conditions after certain land-use actions.
  • Comparing forecasts with later conditions, and tracking mitigation, could identify where future forecasts or mitigation planning may need adjustment.
  • The reports would go to local officials and community boards connected to the affected areas.

Case against#

  • One concern is that the bill requires agency studies and reports but provides no cost estimate or staffing plan.
  • The bill sets a 5% trigger but does not specify how agencies should calculate or compare every metric, which could leave important methods unclear.
  • Recommendations to change the manual are required in specified cases, but the bill does not require the city to adopt them.