Increasing transparency and accountability in the real property tax assessment process

Summary#

Int. 216-2026, sponsored by Council Member Kamillah Hanks, would amend New York City’s Administrative Code; it is not yet law and is waiting in committee. Its stated goal is to increase transparency and accountability in property tax assessments. The Council’s summary describes the main new requirements, but the current code was not supplied, so I could not verify every change against current law.

  • The Department of Finance (DOF) would publish an annual list of parcels personally examined by assessors, including each parcel’s address, examination date, taxable status and examination method.
  • Assessors would have to record the valuation method and why they chose it. For assessments under state Real Property Tax Law section 581, they would also record applicable comparable properties and why they chose them. DOF would keep these records for at least seven years.
  • DOF would publish the guides, manuals, protocols, policies and procedures assessors used during the previous assessment cycle, no later than January 5 each year.
  • Notices of Property Value for qualifying cooperative- and condominium-owned or leased properties would identify applicable comparable properties. If those properties differ from the prior tax year’s, the notice would have to say so and give the reason.
  • The text also says every parcel must be revalued, reassessed or have its assessment updated each assessment cycle, whether or not it was personally examined. Without the current code, it is unclear whether this is a new requirement.

What it means for you#

  • Property owners: If enacted, you could see which parcels assessors examined and how they examined them. The bill does not say that the assessor’s parcel-by-parcel valuation records must be published.
  • Owners of qualifying cooperative or condominium properties: Your notice would identify the comparable properties used for the assessment, where applicable, and explain a change from the prior tax year’s comparables.
  • Other property owners: The bill would not add the comparable-property notice requirement for every type of property. It also would not change tax rates or set a new method for calculating property value.
  • DOF and assessors: They would have to publish the specified information, document valuation choices and retain documentation for at least seven years.

Money#

No cost estimate is in the supplied material.

  • DOF would have to perform the publication, documentation and record-retention duties, but the bill gives no staffing or cost estimate.
  • The text does not create a fee, fine or direct payment to property owners.

What is unclear#

  • The current Administrative Code was not supplied, so it is not possible to confirm which wording restates existing law and which requirements are new.
  • The text says it takes effect July 1, 2024, a date before this 2026 bill’s introduction. It does not explain that date or how the law would apply if enacted later.
  • The bill does not define “assessment cycle” or the methods assessors may use to examine a parcel.
  • It does not set standards for the reasons assessors must record, or say whether owners can access those records or challenge them.
  • It does not change the appeal process. The text retains a provision requiring valuation information to be available at least 30 days before the appeal deadline, but the supplied materials do not establish whether that provision is new.

Case for#

  • The bill appears intended to make assessment practices easier to inspect by requiring DOF to publish examination records and the guidance assessors use.
  • Requiring assessors to record why they chose a valuation method or comparable properties could make assessment decisions easier to explain and scrutinize.
  • Showing comparable properties in qualifying co-op and condo notices could help those owners understand how their assessed value was determined.

Case against#

  • One concern is that documenting every parcel’s valuation method and keeping the records for seven years would add work for DOF and assessors; the cost and staffing needs are unknown.
  • The bill does not set a standard for the reasons assessors must give, so the records may not explain decisions in a consistent or useful way.
  • It is unclear whether the bill’s publication and notice rules would give owners enough information to assess or challenge their own valuations.