Summary#
Int. 0258-2026, sponsored by Council Member Shekar Krishnan, would amend the New York City Administrative Code, including the New York City Human Rights Law. Its text gives it the short title “No exceptions law of 2024.” Its stated goal is to direct courts to interpret the city’s human rights law broadly to protect civil rights.
- It would say there are no exceptions to the law’s liberal-construction rule, and would reject several court interpretations named in the bill.
- It would set out when discrimination has a “non-trivial nexus” (a meaningful connection) to New York City, including some conduct outside the city.
- It would address claims involving mistakenly perceived alcoholism, individual employee or agent liability, and punitive damages.
- It would repeal a paragraph about employer vicarious liability (when an employer is held responsible for another person’s conduct), while also describing how punitive damages may be assessed when a covered entity is found vicariously liable.
- The bill is waiting in committee. It is not law.
What it means for you#
- People bringing discrimination claims: The bill would let a claim have a city connection in several specified situations. These include when the person lived in New York City during some of the time at issue; when the employment, housing, public accommodation, or other listed matter is partly in the city; or when some of the conduct occurred in the city. A factfinder could also find a connection based on other facts.
- Workers and employers: The bill says references in the Human Rights Law to an employer’s or agency’s employees or agents apply to all employees and agents, whether or not they had supervisory authority. It also names employees or agents acting for an employer or employment agency as possible actors in specified employment discrimination and job-advertising provisions.
- People alleging discrimination and covered entities: A finding of liability would be enough for a jury or other factfinder to consider punitive damages; it would not require an award. If damages are considered, the factfinder could weigh the conduct of the liable entity and, for vicarious liability, the conduct of the employee, agent, or independent contractor and the entity’s own actions or failures to act.
- City and its agencies: The bill would waive the city’s immunity to punitive damages for claims under the specified part of the Human Rights Law. That provision, and the bill’s statement that the city waived immunity, would apply only to claims commenced or continued at least one year after the law takes effect.
- The bill says it would take effect immediately and apply retroactively, subject to that one-year limit for the city-immunity provisions.
Money#
No cost information is in the available material.
- The bill gives no estimate of public spending, staffing, or costs to employers or other entities.
- The possibility of punitive damages, including against the city after the one-year period, could create financial exposure; the amount is not stated.
- The bill creates no stated fee or fine.
What is unclear#
- The current text of the amended code was not supplied, so the exact changes from current law—including the full effect of repealing the employer-liability paragraph—cannot be verified. The bill does not explain whether employer vicarious liability continues under other provisions.
- “Covered entity” and “non-trivial nexus” are not defined in the bill. It lists examples of a city connection but also allows a factfinder to consider other facts.
- The bill does not explain how its retroactive application would work in particular ongoing or past cases.
- The text does not set out new claim-filing, decision, or appeal procedures.
Case for#
- The bill’s findings say some courts have interpreted the Human Rights Law narrowly despite earlier Council directions to read it broadly. The bill aims to correct what it calls those misinterpretations.
- The listed city-connection rules could allow claims involving city residents, city-based work or housing, or conduct partly in the city to be considered under city law.
- Treating mistakenly perceived alcoholism as perceived disability, and allowing consideration of punitive damages upon a liability finding, could give effect to the bill’s stated goal of broad civil-rights protection.
Case against#
- The bill could extend the city law to some conduct outside the city, including conduct affecting a person who lived in the city during part of the relevant period. The reach of the open-ended “other facts” test is not fully specified.
- Allowing punitive damages to be considered without requiring intentional, malicious, or reckless conduct could increase potential financial exposure for covered entities, including the city under the delayed provision.
- The repeal’s effect on employer vicarious liability is unclear from the supplied text, even though the bill also discusses cases where a covered entity is vicariously liable.