Requiring the city to report on the impact of social media on the mental health of young people

Summary#

Introduction 0451-2026, sponsored by Council Member Althea V. Stevens, would create a city reporting duty; the supplied text does not identify an existing code or Charter section it would amend. The Department of Youth and Community Development (DYCD), in consultation with the Department of Health and Mental Hygiene (DOHMH), would report on social media’s effects on people under 18. The bill’s stated goal is to inform recommendations about young people’s social media use. It has been laid over in three committees and is not law.

  • DYCD would have to send reports to the Mayor and Council Speaker and post them online.
  • Reports would cover mental-health effects, the most-used apps, uses and apps causing the greatest harm, recommendations on suitable starting age and use, recommended safe time limits, and harms from targeted ads.
  • The bill says reports are due by October 1, 2023, and annually for five consecutive years after that. It would take effect immediately if enacted and be repealed after the final report.

What it means for you#

  • Young people and families: The bill would not set a minimum age, limit hours, ban apps, or require young people to change their use. It requires reports and recommendations.
  • DYCD and DOHMH: DYCD would have the reporting duty and consult DOHMH. The text does not set a research method or say how the departments must gather information.
  • Status: The committees on Children and Youth, Mental Health and Substance Use, and Oversight and Investigations each laid the bill over on April 21, 2026. It remains pending in committee.

Money#

No publicly available information on the cost of preparing the reports.

  • The bill assigns work to DYCD and requires consultation with DOHMH, but gives no staffing or funding amount.

What is unclear#

  • The first stated deadline, October 1, 2023, is before the bill’s introduction in 2026. The text does not explain what happens to that deadline if the bill becomes law later.
  • “Annually thereafter for 5 consecutive years” does not clearly say whether that means five reports total or five reports after the first one.
  • The bill does not set reporting methods, evidence standards, or how the departments should identify the apps and uses causing the greatest harm.

Case for#

  • The bill’s reporting requirement could give the city a regular account of social media’s effects on young people, including effects of targeted ads.
  • Requiring recommendations on age and time spent could help inform public discussion without itself imposing limits on young people or platforms.

Case against#

  • One concern is that the bill sets no research method or evidence standard, so it does not explain how the city would support its findings and recommendations.
  • The stated first deadline has already passed; the bill does not clarify how the reporting schedule would work if enacted.
  • The bill assigns reporting work to two departments but provides no cost estimate or funding details.