Prohibiting smoking on sidewalks immediately adjoining parks, imposing civil penalties for violating such prohibition, and increasing civil penalties for smoking in parks

Summary#

Introduction 0474-2026, sponsored by Council Member Sandra Ung, would amend the New York City Administrative Code. Its stated goal is to prohibit smoking on sidewalks immediately adjoining parks and increase penalties for repeat violations. It was referred to committee on January 29, 2026, and is not law.

  • It would add sidewalks immediately adjoining parks to the places where smoking is prohibited. Exceptions include sidewalks adjoining public places that are not parks, certain pedestrian routes, parking lots, and theatrical productions.
  • For smoking or e-cigarette use in a park, on other property under the Department of Parks and Recreation’s jurisdiction, or on an adjoining sidewalk, the penalty would be $50 for a first violation and $200 for each subsequent violation within 12 months.
  • The bill leaves the $50 penalty for smoking or e-cigarette use in a pedestrian plaza, and the general $100 penalty for other violations of the relevant rule, unchanged.
  • If passed, it would take effect immediately. The committee it is waiting in is not identified in the supplied material.

What it means for you#

  • People using parks and nearby sidewalks: If the bill becomes law, smoking on a sidewalk immediately adjoining a park could result in a $50 civil penalty for a first violation and $200 for each subsequent violation within 12 months. The same penalty schedule would apply to smoking or e-cigarette use in parks and other property under Parks Department jurisdiction.
  • People using listed exceptions: The prohibition would not apply to the specified sidewalks adjoining public places that are not parks, pedestrian routes through park strips, medians or malls next to vehicle traffic, parking lots, or theatrical productions.
  • City agencies: The bill does not assign a new enforcement duty to a named agency or create an enforcement process.
  • General public: Based on the amended wording, the existing rule already covered parks and other Parks Department property; the bill would add adjoining sidewalks and change the penalty for repeat violations. The parent Code provisions were not supplied, so the full current law could not be checked.

Money#

No cost information is in the available material.

  • The bill sets civil penalties at $50 for a first violation and $200 for each subsequent violation within 12 months in the listed park-related locations. It does not say how much revenue those penalties would raise or where it would go.
  • The bill does not provide a spending amount or estimate the cost of enforcement.

What is unclear#

  • The bill does not specify who would enforce the new sidewalk prohibition or how violations would be processed, challenged, or appealed.
  • The supplied text does not define “smoking.” It names e-cigarette use in the penalty provision, but does not explain the term’s full scope.
  • The text does not explain how the listed exceptions would apply in particular locations or cases.

Case for#

  • A possible argument for the bill is that extending the prohibition to sidewalks immediately adjoining parks would create a buffer around park spaces.
  • A possible argument for higher repeat penalties is that a $200 penalty for later violations could give people a stronger reason to follow the rule. The bill sets the penalty but does not state that this result is guaranteed.

Case against#

  • One concern is that the bill creates a new restriction for adjoining sidewalks without setting out enforcement, notice, or appeal procedures.
  • A $200 penalty for a subsequent violation within 12 months is four times the first-violation penalty; the bill gives no explanation for that amount.
  • It is unclear how the rule and exceptions would be applied at park boundaries and nearby public places.