Prohibiting the sale of flavored cigarettes

Summary#

Introduction 0609-2026, sponsored by Council Member Rita C. Joseph, would amend New York City’s Administrative Code. It would add a ban on selling flavored cigarettes and remove the menthol, mint and wintergreen exception from the definition of flavored tobacco products. Its stated goal is not given in the available material; the bill would take effect 90 days after becoming law. It is waiting in committee and is not law.

  • A person could not sell or offer to sell a cigarette that imparts a “characterizing flavor,” including flavors such as menthol, mint, fruit or cooling or numbing sensations.
  • A retail dealer with 400 or more flavored cigarettes would be presumed to be selling them. The bill does not create a presumption based on a smaller quantity.
  • Removing the flavor exception would bring menthol-, mint- and wintergreen-flavored tobacco products within the existing flavored-tobacco-product rule. That rule allows sales in a tobacco bar.
  • A person who is not a retail dealer could still buy, use or possess flavored cigarettes. The bill does not ban those activities.
  • Civil penalties could reach $5,000 for later violations. For a retail dealer’s third violation on a different day, and later violations on different days, the dealer’s license could be suspended for up to one year.

What it means for you#

  • Retailers: You could not sell or offer to sell flavored cigarettes. If you have at least 400, the bill presumes you are selling them. It does not set out a process for deciding whether a product imparts a characterizing flavor.
  • People who buy or use flavored cigarettes: The bill does not prohibit your purchase, use or possession unless you are engaged in business as a retail dealer.
  • People who buy flavored tobacco products: The existing tobacco-product restriction would cover menthol, mint and wintergreen flavors too, but sales in a tobacco bar remain excepted.
  • Enforcement: The bill sets penalties but does not name the city agency that would enforce them.

Money#

No publicly available information on the bill’s costs.

  • The bill creates no stated appropriation or fee. It would allow civil penalties of up to $1,000 for a first violation, up to $2,000 for a second violation at the same business within three years, and up to $5,000 for a third or later violation there within three years. Additional violations found on the same day are subject to the same applicable maximum.
  • After a third violation on a different day, and for later violations on different days within three years, a retail dealer’s license for that business must be suspended for up to one year. The suspension would occur at the hearing where the dealer is found liable.

What is unclear#

  • The bill does not name the agency responsible for enforcement or provide investigation, hearing or appeal details.
  • “Characterizing flavor” includes a distinguishable taste or aroma beyond tobacco, as well as cooling or numbing sensations and “concept” flavors. The bill does not set out how officials would test or decide whether a product meets that standard.
  • The bill does not estimate enforcement, business compliance or staffing costs.
  • The available material does not explain how the new cigarette ban would interact with other city or state rules.

Case for#

  • The bill appears intended to restrict retail sales of cigarettes and tobacco products with flavors beyond tobacco. Applying the existing flavored-product restriction to menthol, mint and wintergreen would close that stated flavor exception.
  • A possible argument for the 400-cigarette presumption is that it gives an enforcement rule for larger retail inventories while not making possession by ordinary consumers an offense.

Case against#

  • One concern is that the definition includes a wide range of tastes, aromas and sensations, but the bill does not specify how flavor would be determined in disputed cases.
  • Retailers face civil penalties of up to $5,000 and possible mandatory license suspension, while the bill does not name the enforcing agency or explain the hearing process.
  • The 400-cigarette presumption may make a retailer’s inventory relevant evidence of sale, even though the bill does not explain how a retailer could rebut that presumption.