Increasing oversight of certified asbestos investigators

Summary#

Introduction 498, sponsored by Council Member Nantasha M. Williams, would amend New York City’s Administrative Code on certification of asbestos investigators. It would require the Department of Environmental Protection (DEP) to check backgrounds, require experience investigating buildings for asbestos, and audit at least 25% of certificate holders each year. The stated goal is increased oversight; the bill is waiting in committee and is not law.

  • Each new asbestos-investigator applicant and each certificate holder seeking renewal would need a background check.
  • Applicants would have to show experience investigating buildings for asbestos.
  • DEP would have to audit at least 25% of certificate holders annually for compliance.
  • The text also includes rules on certificate terms, suspension and revocation, fees, and other matters. Because the current version of the Administrative Code was not supplied, it is unclear which of these provisions would change existing law.

What it means for you#

  • Asbestos-investigator applicants and certificate holders: The bill would require background checks for new applicants and for holders seeking renewal; applicants would also have to demonstrate relevant building-investigation experience.
  • Asbestos investigators: DEP would have to audit at least one quarter of certificate holders each year. The bill does not say which holders would be selected.
  • People and businesses hiring investigators: The bill does not directly change hiring rules or require them to use a particular investigator.

Money#

The bill requires DEP to perform background checks and annual audits, but no cost estimate is available.

  • The amended text sets a maximum application-processing fee of $500 for asbestos investigators. The supplied materials do not show whether this changes the current fee.
  • The text also sets a maximum fee of $200 for asbestos-handling certificates; whether that changes the current fee is unclear.

What is unclear#

  • The bill does not define “background check” or say what information it covers.
  • It does not set standards for the experience applicants must demonstrate.
  • It does not explain how DEP would choose certificate holders for audits or what happens after an audit finds a problem.
  • The current Administrative Code text was not supplied, so the extent of the changes to existing rules and fees cannot be verified.
  • The bill would take effect 120 days after it becomes law.

Case for#

  • The Council’s summary says the bill is intended to increase oversight of certified asbestos investigators.
  • Requiring relevant experience and background checks could add screening before certification or renewal.
  • Auditing at least 25% of certificate holders annually would set a minimum level of oversight in law.

Case against#

  • The bill does not define the background check or the experience standard, leaving important requirements for DEP rules.
  • The bill requires checks and audits but provides no cost estimate or detail on the staff and resources DEP would need.
  • It is unclear how audits would be selected and what process would apply if an audit identifies a problem.