Requiring the department of investigation to investigate the fire department’s compliance with laws and policies relating to discrimination, harassment, and equal employment opportunity

Summary#

Int. 0505-2026, sponsored by Council Member Nantasha M. Williams, would amend the New York City Charter to require the Department of Investigation (DOI) to examine the Fire Department’s compliance with laws and policies on discrimination, harassment, and equal employment opportunity. Its stated purpose is to require ongoing investigation and reporting; it does not guarantee that violations will be found or corrected. The bill was introduced and referred to committee on January 29, 2026, and is not law.

  • DOI’s commissioner would have to investigate, review, study, audit, and make recommendations about FDNY and its employees’ compliance with federal, state, and city laws and policies.
  • The review must include promotion and special-operations assignments, how FDNY handles complaints (including typical timelines), and retaliation against employees who complain.
  • DOI would have to provide a webpage where people may submit information without giving personally identifying information. The page must warn that DOI might not investigate every complaint and direct people seeking an individual complaint investigation to other options.
  • DOI would have to report findings and recommendations to the mayor and Council speaker within one year after the law takes effect, then every two years. Reports must update the status of earlier recommendations.
  • The law would take effect one year after it becomes law.

What it means for you#

  • FDNY and its employees: DOI would be required to examine their compliance in the areas listed above. The bill does not require FDNY to adopt DOI’s recommendations.
  • People submitting information: You could provide information through DOI’s webpage without identifying yourself. The webpage must explain that DOI may use submissions to investigate patterns or practices, but may not investigate every complaint. This is not a guaranteed process for investigating an individual complaint.
  • DOI: The commissioner would have ongoing investigative and reporting duties.
  • People seeking an individual complaint investigation: The webpage must direct them to consider a private attorney or file with the New York City Commission on Human Rights, the New York State Division of Human Rights, or another agency that investigates individual complaints.

Money#

No cost estimate is provided in the available material.

  • DOI would have to carry out ongoing work, maintain a webpage, and submit reports, but the bill gives no staffing or cost estimate.
  • The bill does not state an appropriation, fee, fine, or payment.

What is unclear#

  • The bill does not specify how DOI must conduct the review or what evidence it must examine.
  • It does not define key terms such as “ongoing” or “special operations command units.”
  • It does not say how DOI should protect, retain, or share information submitted through the webpage.
  • The available material does not include the current Charter text, so the existing scope of DOI’s authority and how this duty would interact with it cannot be verified here.
  • The bill requires recommendations and updates, but does not set deadlines for FDNY to respond to or implement them.

Case for#

  • The bill’s design could help DOI identify patterns across promotions, special assignments, complaint handling, and retaliation, rather than treating each submitted account only as an individual complaint.
  • Anonymous submissions may let people provide information without identifying themselves.
  • Required reports could give the mayor and Council regular findings and recommendations, including updates on prior recommendations.

Case against#

  • DOI would have to investigate on an ongoing basis, but the bill does not provide a cost estimate or specify staffing.
  • DOI may use webpage submissions to examine patterns, but it is not required to investigate every complaint. People seeking individual investigations must look to other channels.
  • The bill does not require FDNY to act on DOI’s recommendations, so the reports alone may not change FDNY practices.