Issuing newsstand licenses to operate abandoned newsstands and requiring an assessment of the viability of the location of new newsstands

Summary#

Introduction 536, sponsored by Council Member Oswald J. Feliz, would amend the New York City Administrative Code rules for newsstand licenses. It would let operators seek licenses for certain abandoned stands without reimbursing the franchisee for construction and installation costs, and require the Department of Transportation (DOT) to consider pedestrian traffic when approving a location. The stated goal is to allow operation of abandoned stands and assess whether locations for new stands are viable.

  • The bill defines an “abandoned newsstand” as a qualifying stand whose license was revoked after the commissioner found its location had not been used for at least two consecutive months.
  • An operator would not have to reimburse a franchisee for construction and installation costs to get a license for a stand that is a replacement or meets that abandoned-stand definition. Other eligibility rules, including an income test, remain in the amended text.
  • DOT would have to consider pedestrian traffic when approving a location, both to help ensure a clear path and to indicate the stand’s likely success.
  • The bill is waiting in committee. It is not law; if it becomes law, it would take effect 120 days later.

What it means for you#

  • Newsstand operators: An operator could apply to run a qualifying abandoned stand without first reimbursing the franchisee for construction and installation costs. The bill does not guarantee a license.
  • Applicants and business owners: The text retains the rule that the operator’s other income, excluding investment income, must not exceed income from operating the newsstand. For a business entity, the test applies to each shareholder, partner, member, or principal.
  • DOT: The department would have to consider pedestrian traffic when approving a location. The bill does not set a minimum traffic level or say that low traffic requires denial.
  • Franchisees: For a qualifying abandoned stand, a new operator would not have to reimburse the franchisee for those costs as a condition of getting a license.

Money#

No cost information is in the available material.

  • The bill removes a reimbursement condition for operators of qualifying abandoned stands; it gives no cost amounts or estimate of the financial effect.
  • It does not state a new appropriation, fee, or fine.

What is unclear#

  • The current text of the amended code was not supplied, so the precise difference from current law could not be verified.
  • The bill does not explain how DOT should weigh pedestrian traffic or how it should balance likely success against keeping a clear path.
  • It does not set a process, timeline, or appeal for license applications or location approvals.
  • The definition of “not utilized” is not further explained.

Case for#

  • The Council’s summary says the bill would allow licensees to operate abandoned stands and have DOT consider foot traffic. This could make some previously unused locations available without requiring the next operator to repay the franchisee’s construction costs.
  • Considering pedestrian traffic could help DOT weigh both pedestrian clearance and whether a location is likely to support a newsstand.

Case against#

  • One concern is that the bill gives no threshold or detailed criteria for DOT’s decision, so applicants may not know how pedestrian traffic will affect approval.
  • The bill removes the reimbursement requirement for qualifying abandoned stands but does not explain how the franchisee’s construction and installation costs would otherwise be addressed.