Summary#
Int 557, sponsored by Council Member James F. Gennaro, is a proposed local law amending New York City’s Administrative Code. It would require the Department of Housing Preservation and Development (HPD) to create an energy-efficiency program for multiple dwellings; its stated goal is reflected in the program’s name, but the bill does not guarantee energy savings. The bill was introduced and referred to committee on February 12, 2026, and is waiting in that committee.
- HPD must create the program and a list of eligible energy-efficiency measures.
- Owners with certain non-hazardous violations could have civil penalties waived or reduced if they sign an agreement with HPD to undertake eligible measures.
- The agreement must say that those measures cannot be the basis for a rent increase.
- The listed measures include building-shell improvements, lighting upgrades, energy-efficient appliances and programmable thermostats. For buildings up to 25,000 gross square feet, they must also include benchmarking, energy audits and retro-commissioning measures.
- If an owner does not comply with the agreement, the original penalties may be reinstated or doubled.
- The law would take effect 180 days after it becomes law. HPD must take steps needed for implementation, including making rules, before then.
What it means for you#
- Multiple-dwelling owners: You could seek penalty relief for a violation only if it is non-hazardous and HPD’s rules list it as eligible. You would have to sign an agreement and undertake eligible measures. The bill does not set out an application or decision process.
- Renters: The agreement must prevent the eligible measures from being used as a basis for a rent increase. The bill does not say that all rent increases are barred.
- HPD: The department must create the program, make rules identifying eligible violations and create the list of eligible measures.
- General public: The bill does not create a new independent agency or provide a direct public service.
Money#
The bill requires HPD to do implementation work, but the available material gives no cost estimate.
- Owners would spend money on measures required by their agreement; the bill does not estimate those costs.
- Civil penalties could be waived or reduced. The text says penalties are to be reduced to an amount equal to what the owner spends on measures, but also allows penalties to be waived; how these provisions work together is unclear.
- For multiple eligible violations, an owner may combine penalties up to $3,000 for the purpose of undertaking measures.
What is unclear#
- HPD’s rules would determine which non-hazardous violations qualify. The bill does not identify them.
- The bill does not explain how owners apply, how HPD decides, or how disputes or missed deadlines are handled.
- It is unclear how the penalty-reduction formula works alongside the option to waive penalties, especially when the cost of measures differs from the penalty amount.
- The parent Administrative Code is not included, so the existing penalties and processes—and how much of the bill changes them—could not be checked.
- The bill does not specify how compliance will be monitored or when an original penalty would be doubled rather than reinstated.
Case for#
- The bill’s design suggests a way to encourage building improvements by allowing owners to use penalty relief to help pay for eligible energy-efficiency measures.
- A possible argument for the program is that it links relief to specific work rather than granting it without conditions.
- The bill requires that the agreed measures not be used as a basis for a rent increase.
Case against#
- One concern is that the bill does not explain how HPD will choose eligible violations or decide which measures an owner must undertake.
- Penalty relief could reduce penalty revenue, but the bill gives no estimate of how often relief might be used or its financial effect.
- The penalty provisions may be hard to apply because the bill allows penalties to be waived or reduced, while also setting a formula for the reduced amount.
- Owners who do not comply could face reinstated or doubled penalties, but the bill does not describe the compliance process.