An expansion of the alternative enforcement program

Summary#

Introduction 1086-2026 would amend the New York City Administrative Code provisions for the existing Alternative Enforcement Program (AEP), run by the Department of Housing Preservation and Development (HPD). Its stated goal is to expand the program’s use to address distressed buildings. The bill was introduced by Council Member Farah N. Louis and referred to committee on September 24, 2026; it is not law.

  • HPD would have to identify at least 400 different distressed buildings for AEP each year, no later than March 1. The current text shown in the bill requires at least 250 a year.
  • At least 100 of the buildings identified each year would have to be distressed buildings previously discharged from AEP.
  • HPD would set the criteria for identifying buildings, including criteria for previously discharged buildings. If too few buildings meet the criteria, HPD would have to set criteria to identify additional buildings.
  • The bill keeps exclusions for certain buildings, including some under city foreclosure or administrator proceedings, and some with recently closed rehabilitation loans.
  • Existing AEP buildings would remain subject to the program until discharged. The bill does not create a new independent agency.

What it means for you#

  • Tenants in selected buildings: More buildings could be selected for the existing program, including buildings that have been discharged and are distressed again. The bill does not set out new tenant services or explain the program’s specific requirements for tenants.
  • Building owners: More buildings could be brought into AEP. The bill leaves HPD to set selection criteria; it does not itself create an application or appeal process.
  • HPD: The department would have to identify at least 400 buildings each year and ensure at least 100 are previously discharged buildings. It would also have to set selection criteria and criteria for identifying additional buildings if too few qualify.
  • General public: The bill does not directly change taxes, rents, or housing eligibility rules.

Money#

No cost estimate is provided in the available material.

  • HPD would have to carry out the expanded selection work, but the bill gives no staffing or budget amount.
  • The bill does not set new fees or fines.

What is unclear#

  • What HPD’s criteria will be, including how it will decide which eligible buildings are selected first.
  • How HPD will identify additional buildings if fewer than 400—or fewer than 100 previously discharged buildings—meet its initial criteria.
  • What staffing or funding HPD will need, and how the expansion will affect the existing program.
  • The bill does not define “distressed” on its own; it directs HPD to set criteria. It also does not establish an application, review, or appeal process.
  • The parent Administrative Code is not supplied, so the bill’s text does not allow a full check of current AEP requirements beyond the current wording shown in the proposed amendments.

Case for#

  • A possible argument for the bill is that increasing the annual minimum would let HPD target more distressed buildings through a program already in place.
  • Including at least 100 previously discharged buildings could focus attention on buildings that become distressed again after leaving the program.
  • HPD could set criteria that account for factors such as hazardous violations, emergency repair charges, building size, prior program outcomes, and changes in ownership.

Case against#

  • One concern is that requiring 400 buildings each year could lead HPD to broaden its criteria if fewer buildings meet its initial standards; the bill leaves those choices to HPD.
  • The bill sets a minimum number but does not specify how HPD will prioritize buildings, beyond requiring it to set criteria by rule.
  • The expansion requires more HPD work, but the bill provides no cost estimate or staffing plan.