Summary#
Introduction 624, sponsored by Council Member Frank Morano, would amend New York City’s Administrative Code section 16-120. It would create exemptions from Department of Sanitation (DSNY) rules requiring buildings with nine or fewer homes to put refuse in rigid, tightly lidded containers. The bill’s apparent goal is to exempt buildings where storing those containers is not workable. It is in committee and is not law; the available history shows it was introduced and referred to committee on February 12, 2026.
- Some buildings would be exempt automatically: those under 5,000 square feet with ground-floor commercial space and specified tight clearances from their lot lines. Buildings meeting other exemption criteria DSNY sets by rule would also qualify.
- An owner could apply if there is no place on the property to store the containers without creating one of four listed problems, including violating fire or housing codes or moving residential containers through a commercial tenant’s space.
- DSNY would have to provide an online form, decide applications within 60 days, keep a registry of known exempt buildings, and conduct ongoing outreach and education.
- A denied applicant could appeal to the Office of Administrative Trials and Hearings (OATH), generally within 30 days—or 35 days if the denial was mailed. Certain violations would have to be dismissed while an application or appeal is pending, or if the building meets exemption criteria.
- An exempt building issued a violation for failing to use the containers could recover reasonable costs and attorney’s fees for defending against it.
What it means for you#
- Building owners and property managers: If the bill becomes law, you would not need to apply for an automatic exemption, though you could voluntarily provide DSNY information about it. To seek an exemption based on storage problems, you would have to apply and satisfy DSNY. The bill does not set out what evidence an application must include.
- Residential and commercial tenants: The bill could affect how refuse is stored at some mixed-use buildings. It does not create a tenant application or appeal process.
- DSNY and OATH: DSNY would have new duties to handle applications, keep a registry, provide outreach, and make rules. OATH would hear appeals.
- All building owners: The proposal addresses only the specified container rules. It does not exempt buildings from other sanitation requirements.
Money#
The bill requires new DSNY work, but no cost estimate is provided.
- DSNY would have to process applications, maintain a registry, conduct an ongoing education campaign, and make rules. The bill gives no staffing or funding estimate.
- An exempt building could recover reasonable defense costs and attorney’s fees from DSNY if it is issued a covered violation.
- The bill does not state an application fee.
What is unclear#
- The bill does not define how DSNY would decide whether an owner has shown there is “no location” for storage to its satisfaction.
- DSNY must set rules, but the bill does not specify the application evidence, decision process, or timing for those rules.
- The automatic exemption criteria include an option for DSNY to establish other criteria by rule; the bill does not set limits on those criteria.
- The current text of the amended code was not supplied, so the full current requirements and how the proposed changes fit with them could not be verified.
Case for#
- The bill appears intended to address buildings where container storage could conflict with fire or housing codes, require moving residential refuse through commercial space, or leave containers in the public right-of-way or inside a home.
- A possible argument for the exemptions is that requiring containers where there is no suitable storage location may create practical problems the exemption process could recognize.
- Requiring DSNY to decide applications within 60 days and allowing appeals could give owners a defined route to seek a decision.
Case against#
- One concern is that the bill does not spell out what evidence DSNY should require or how it should assess storage options, leaving important decisions to agency rules and individual determinations.
- The bill requires some violations to be dismissed while an application or appeal is unresolved. That could limit enforcement during those periods, even though the bill does not set deadlines for OATH to decide appeals.
- DSNY would take on application, registry, outreach, and rulemaking duties without a stated budget or staffing plan.