Summary#
Introduction 0683-2026, sponsored by Council Member Julie Won, would amend the New York City Charter by adding rules for public review of certain electronic services developed by city agencies. Its stated goal is to let intended users recommend improvements to a service’s accessibility, operation and functionality before it opens to the public. It is waiting in committee and is not law.
- Covered agencies would have to review each new public-facing electronic service with members of its “relevant communities” before operating it for public use. The bill exempts services already in use when the law takes effect.
- Agencies would have to seek 200 participants per review, or use as many as they can get. If they get fewer than 10, they may open the service without a review, but must report on outreach and plans to improve participation.
- Agencies would have to give notice at least 60 days before a review, including how to apply and who may take part. The Mayor’s Office of Operations, working with the Department of Citywide Administrative Services and the Department of Information Technology and Telecommunications, would have to maintain a website for review information and applications.
- Agencies would have to consider participants’ recommendations, but would not have to adopt them. After opening a service, an agency would have to report on changes it made—or why it made none.
- The Mayor’s Office of Operations would make rules for reviews and decide, within five days, on agency requests to skip review when a service is needed for immediate public use. The bill also says an agency need not review a service if it can demonstrate an immediate public need.
What it means for you#
- Residents and business owners who may use a service: You could apply online to take part in a review if the agency selects people from your relevant community. The bill does not guarantee that you will be selected or that the agency will make changes based on your feedback.
- People with accessibility, language-access or digital-literacy needs: Agencies would have to consider language-access and digital-literacy needs when developing a service, and participants could recommend accessibility improvements.
- Covered city agencies: The requirement applies to mayor-appointed agency heads and certain executive-office units designated by the Mayor. It excludes agencies headed by boards or commissions, elected officials, and agencies whose heads are appointed by others. It covers mobile applications, websites and digital platforms used to interact with the public to provide services or benefits, but not informational-only publications or websites.
- The bill would take effect 180 days after it becomes law. It does not create a private right to sue over its requirements.
Money#
The bill requires agency work and a public website, but the available material gives no cost estimate.
- Agencies would have to conduct reviews, give advance notice and report on participant feedback and outreach.
- The Mayor’s Office of Operations would have to make rules and maintain the website with the two named departments. No staffing levels or funding are specified.
What is unclear#
- The bill leaves the details of participant selection and review procedures to rules. It does not set selection criteria or explain how agencies should handle reviews with 10 to 199 participants.
- The text does not explain how an agency’s immediate-public-need request should be assessed beyond requiring a decision within five days. It also separately says an agency need not review a service if it can demonstrate an immediate public need.
- The supplied material does not include the current Charter text, so it does not show whether any similar requirements already exist.
- The bill does not set a deadline for agencies to publish their post-launch reports.
Case for#
- The bill’s design gives intended users a chance to identify access or usability problems before a new service opens to the public.
- Public notices, online applications and published reports could make the review process visible and show how agencies respond to recommendations.
- The bill requires agencies to consider community needs, while leaving them able to open a service after considering feedback.
Case against#
- A review, advance outreach and reporting could add time and work before a service opens; the bill provides no cost estimate or funding plan.
- Agencies need not adopt recommendations, and the bill creates no private right of action. The text does not specify another way for the public to enforce the requirements.
- The under-10-participant and immediate-need exceptions could allow a service to open without a public review; the bill does not fully explain how the immediate-need exception works in practice.