Requiring comprehensive reporting and oversight of the use of surveillance technology for law enforcement purposes by certain agencies

Summary#

Int. 0690-2026 is a proposed local law, sponsored by Council Member Gale A. Brewer, to amend New York City’s Administrative Code. Its stated goal is more reporting and oversight of law-enforcement surveillance technology; it would require six city agencies to publish policies and restrict some sharing and use of surveillance data. The bill is waiting in committee and is not law.

  • The Fire Department, Department of Correction, Department of Probation, Department of Investigation, Department of Finance, and Office of Emergency Management would have to publish impact and use policies for surveillance technology.
  • For new, distinct technology, an agency head would have to post a proposed policy at least 90 days before use. For technology the agency already possesses, the proposal would be due within 180 days after the law takes effect.
  • The policies would identify how government agencies can or must get data, known task-force access, and any known sharing with federal immigration agencies and steps taken to limit civil immigration enforcement use.
  • The public would have 45 days to comment on proposed policies. Agency heads would have to consider comments and publish final policies within 45 days after that comment period closes.
  • The Police Commissioner could not use a responder agency’s technology or data, or ask that agency to use technology for a Police Department law-enforcement action, if doing so would circumvent Police Department policies. Responder agencies also could not use or request Police Department technology or data in a way that violates their data-sharing policies.

What it means for you#

  • Residents and the public: You would be able to comment on proposed policies. The bill does not create an individual approval process or a general ban on surveillance technology.
  • The six responder agencies: Their heads would have to write, publish, and update policies. An addendum would be required for enhancements or new uses not previously disclosed; routine updates that do not materially change function or capability are exempt.
  • People affected by facial recognition: A facial-recognition policy would have to describe its capabilities and use, access restrictions and oversight, image-modification guidelines, training requirements, and potentially disparate impacts on protected groups.
  • Police Department: Its use of responder-agency technology and data would be limited only where the specified policy-circumvention condition applies; the bill does not bar all such use.
  • The bill changes existing Administrative Code provisions. The supplied materials do not include the current text of those provisions, so the exact change to existing requirements cannot be independently verified.

Money#

No cost information is in the available material.

  • The bill requires agency heads to prepare, publish, and update policies and consider public comments, but gives no cost or staffing estimate and makes no stated appropriation.

What is unclear#

  • The bill relies on existing definitions and policy requirements in the Administrative Code, including the definition of a surveillance technology impact and use policy. The current text of those provisions was not supplied.
  • The bill does not set out a separate process for checking whether agencies follow their policies, or specify penalties for non-compliance.
  • It is unclear whether addenda for enhancements or new uses receive the same public-comment process; the comment rule expressly refers to proposals required for new or existing technology.
  • The bill does not specify how agencies should resolve disputes about whether technologies are distinct or whether a use would circumvent a policy.

Case for#

  • The Council’s summary describes a need for comprehensive reporting and oversight. Requiring agencies to disclose planned uses and data-sharing rules could make those practices more visible.
  • A public comment period gives people a chance to raise concerns before policies are finalized.
  • The limits on cross-agency use could help prevent agencies from using another agency’s technology or data to get around their own policies.

Case against#

  • One concern is that writing, publishing, updating, and reviewing policies would add work for six agencies, but the bill gives no cost or staffing estimate.
  • The bill does not specify a compliance-checking process or consequences if an agency fails to follow its policy.
  • It is unclear how disagreements about distinct technologies or policy circumvention would be resolved, which could make the limits hard to apply consistently.