Establishing a commission to develop a citywide shelter siting plan for implementation by the department of homeless services and social services

Summary#

Introduction 0773-2026, sponsored by Public Advocate Jumaane Williams, would amend New York City’s Administrative Code to create a Commission on Shelter Siting. Its stated goal is to plan shelter locations in relation to residents’ communities of origin, public transit and essential services. It is waiting in committee and is not law.

  • The 15-member commission would study shelter locations and needs, seek input from community boards and the public, and develop a five-year citywide plan for placing, locating or relocating shelters.
  • The Mayor, City Council Speaker and borough presidents would each appoint five members. The Mayor would choose the chair.
  • The commission would review and update the plan each year, report annually, and meet at least once every four months, including at least one public meeting each year.
  • The commissioners of Homeless Services and Social Services would have to provide staff to assist the commission and implement its plan.
  • The bill would also change an existing reporting requirement about the projected number of shelter facilities to be built or rehabilitated, tying it to the siting plan.

What it means for you#

  • People who use shelters: The commission would consider access to communities of origin, transit and essential services when planning shelter locations. The bill does not guarantee particular locations or improved access.
  • Community boards and the public: The commission would have to solicit their input on shelter placement and distribution. The bill does not set out how input would be gathered or how it would affect the plan.
  • City agencies: The Homeless Services and Social Services commissioners would have to provide staff and implement the plan.
  • Taxpayers: The bill requires agency staff support but gives no staffing level or cost estimate.
  • Current law: The supplied materials do not include the full current Administrative Code, so it is not possible to verify what shelter-planning duties or requirements already exist.

Money#

The bill requires agency staff support, but no cost information is in the available materials.

  • The commissioners of Homeless Services and Social Services must provide “appropriate personnel.” The bill does not say how many staff or what this would cost.
  • It requires the commission to consider finances needed for shelters, but does not provide funding or a spending amount.

What is unclear#

  • The text sets the first plan deadline at December 1, 2022, and the first report deadline at the same date—deadlines already past. It does not explain how those dates would work if the bill became law later.
  • A provision says the annual update would review a plan developed under a different part of the bill; that part describes the commission’s duties, not the plan. The text does not resolve this apparent cross-reference error.
  • The bill does not define “essential services” or set criteria for deciding where shelters should go.
  • It does not describe how the commission would choose sites, resolve disagreements, or oversee implementation.
  • The bill says it takes effect only after it is submitted to city voters at the next general election after enactment and approved by a majority voting on it. The materials do not explain how that voter-approval step would be carried out.

Case for#

  • The bill’s text identifies a planning problem: shelter locations should be considered in relation to residents’ communities of origin, transit and essential services.
  • A citywide plan, updated annually, could give agencies a shared basis for planning shelter placement and relocation.
  • Requiring public and community-board input could bring local views into that planning.
  • The commission would also examine shelter needs, finances and alternative or emergency services, rather than location alone.

Case against#

  • The bill gives the commission broad siting duties but does not set site-selection criteria or explain how its decisions would be made.
  • The Homeless Services and Social Services commissioners must implement the plan, but the bill does not spell out the implementation process or how conflicts with other needs would be handled.
  • The required staff support could use agency resources, but the bill provides no cost estimate or staffing limit.
  • The past-due 2022 deadlines and apparent cross-reference error could make the required timing and plan-update duties uncertain.