Civil penalties for failure to remove snow or ice

Summary#

Introduction 0868-2026, sponsored by Council Member Simcha Felder, would amend the New York City Administrative Code. It would limit when the Department of Sanitation (DSNY) can issue snow- and ice-related violations, appearance tickets, or summonses under existing rules. Its apparent goal is to wait until city agencies have completed their own snow and ice removal before DSNY issues these penalties.

  • Before DSNY can issue a notice, ticket, or summons for a violation of the existing sidewalk rules, it must finish removing snow and ice from streets under its jurisdiction.
  • The transportation and parks commissioners must certify to the DSNY commissioner that their departments have finished removing snow and ice from infrastructure under their jurisdictions. They may submit the certification in writing or electronically.
  • The bill lists examples of infrastructure, including streets, ramps, pathways, bridges, plazas, greenways, playgrounds, and step streets.
  • The bill is waiting in committee; it has not become law. If enacted, it would take effect 120 days after becoming law.

What it means for you#

  • Property owners: The Council summary describes the existing rules as requiring property owners to clear snow or ice from abutting sidewalks. The bill would delay DSNY enforcement under those rules until the agency-completion conditions are met. It does not remove the underlying clearing requirement. The parent law was not supplied, so the exact existing duty and penalties could not be verified.
  • Residents: The bill changes the timing of enforcement, not the stated snow-removal duties. It does not set a deadline for when DSNY, the transportation department, or the parks department must finish clearing.

Money#

No cost information is in the available material.

What is unclear#

  • The text does not state the geographic scope of the agencies’ required completion certifications.
  • It does not set deadlines for clearing or for submitting certifications, or explain how completion will be checked.
  • The parent law was not supplied, so the exact sidewalk duties and penalties under the rules the bill cites could not be verified.
  • The bill does not describe how this condition would interact with existing snow-removal enforcement processes.

Case for#

  • A possible argument for the bill is that DSNY should not issue penalties for sidewalk clearing until city agencies have completed their own snow and ice removal. The bill’s conditions would make that order explicit.
  • Requiring written or electronic certifications could give DSNY a record that the transportation and parks departments reported completion.

Case against#

  • One concern is that the bill gives no deadline for agency completion or certification. That could delay DSNY’s ability to issue penalties, even if a sidewalk remains uncleared.
  • The certification covers infrastructure under the transportation and parks departments’ respective jurisdictions, but the text does not explain the geographic scope or how completion will be verified.