Digital verification of food protection certificates and penalties for failure to maintain a physical certificate on premises

Summary#

Int. 0908-2026, sponsored by Council Member Kayla Santosuosso, would amend the New York City Administrative Code’s food-protection law. Its stated aim is to let the Department of Health and Mental Hygiene (DOHMH) verify food protection certificates digitally and prevent a penalty based only on a missing paper certificate when the certificate is valid in the system. The bill was laid over in the Health Committee after a hearing and is not law.

  • DOHMH would have to maintain and operate a secure, searchable digital system listing all valid food protection certifications it issued.
  • Authorized DOHMH staff could use the system to verify a person’s certification during a sanitary inspection or other enforcement action.
  • During a sanitary inspection, digital verification of a valid certificate would count as full compliance with the food-protection course and certification requirement.
  • A food service establishment could not be penalized solely because the physical certificate was not on site, if the required certificate holder’s status was verified as valid in the system.
  • The rewritten section retains a $400 civil penalty for violating its food-protection requirement. The bill would take effect 180 days after it becomes law.

What it means for you#

  • Food service establishments and managers: The bill would not remove the requirement for the person managing or supervising operations to meet the food-protection course and certification requirement. It would allow digital verification during a sanitary inspection to satisfy that requirement, even without a paper certificate on site.
  • DOHMH: The department would have to build or maintain and operate the digital system. The bill limits access to authorized department personnel.
  • Customers and the general public: The bill does not change food-safety standards or create a new public-facing certificate search system.

Money#

The bill requires DOHMH to operate a digital system, but the available material gives no cost estimate.

  • The bill does not specify funding, staffing levels, or the system’s operating cost.
  • The stated $400 civil penalty is retained in the rewritten section; the bill does not set a new penalty amount.

What is unclear#

  • The current text of the amended Administrative Code section and the related Health Code rule were not supplied, so it is not possible to verify what requirements or penalties already apply, or how much of the rewritten text is new.
  • The bill does not explain how inspectors would access the system if it is unavailable, or how a certificate holder could address an incorrect or missing record.
  • It does not set details for system security, record retention, or how long it would take DOHMH to establish the system.
  • The bill does not say how the $400 penalty would apply to other violations of the food-protection requirement.

Case for#

  • The bill’s design would let inspectors verify valid certification without relying on a paper copy being present at the establishment.
  • It would protect an establishment from a penalty based solely on a missing physical certificate when DOHMH’s system confirms the required person is certified.
  • The bill still requires the responsible manager or supervisor to meet the course and certification requirement.

Case against#

  • One concern is that the bill depends on a secure, searchable system but does not set out what happens during an outage or when the system has an inaccurate record.
  • It is unclear how much the system would cost to build and operate, or what staff and resources DOHMH would need.
  • The bill does not specify system safeguards beyond requiring it to be secure, or explain how certificate holders could correct errors.