Summary#
Introduction 925-2026, sponsored by Council Member Joann Ariola, would amend the New York City Administrative Code’s penalty table. It would raise penalties for excessive noise from a personal audio device on or inside a motor vehicle; the bill’s apparent goal is to make repeat violations more costly. It has only been introduced and referred to committee, so it is not law.
- For the violation listed in the bill as section 24-233(b)(2), the proposed penalty would be $200–$700 for a first violation, $400–$1,400 for a second, and $600–$2,100 for a third or later violation.
- Repeat violations count when they involve the same respondent and the same provision, and were committed within two years. For a respondent who owns, leases, or controls the premises, the table also requires the violations to be at the same premises.
- The bill does not name an agency responsible for enforcement.
What it means for you#
- Drivers and other people who may be held responsible: If found liable for this violation, you could face higher penalties than under the amounts shown in brackets as the existing amounts: $100–$350 for a first violation, $200–$700 for a second, and $300–$1,050 for a third or later violation.
- Other city residents and businesses: The bill does not directly change rules for other noise violations; it changes one entry in the penalty table.
- The supplied material does not include the current text of the Administrative Code section defining the violation, so its full legal scope could not be checked.
Money#
No publicly available information on the bill’s implementation costs or expected revenue.
- The bill would raise the listed minimum and maximum penalties. It gives no estimate of how much additional penalty revenue might result.
What is unclear#
- The bill does not explain why these penalty amounts were chosen or how the city would enforce the rule.
- The supplied material does not say which agency handles enforcement, or whether the bill would change the existing enforcement process.
- The bill’s history shows referral to committee, with no hearing, vote, or enactment recorded in the supplied material.
Case for#
- The bill appears intended to make penalties for excessive noise from a personal audio device on or inside a motor vehicle more significant, especially for repeat violations.
- A possible argument for the change is that higher penalties may better discourage repeat violations. The supplied material does not say whether this effect is expected or supported by evidence.
Case against#
- One concern is that people found liable could face substantially higher penalties, but the bill gives no reason for the specific increases.
- It is unclear how enforcement would work or what safeguards would apply; the bill does not set out those details.