Requiring the parks department to repair damage caused by trees owned by the city of New York

Summary#

Introduction 0946-2026, sponsored by Council Member Kevin C. Riley, would amend New York City’s Administrative Code rules on sidewalk maintenance. Despite its title and the Council summary, the bill’s text does not require the Parks Department to repair damage: it would exempt some homeowners from repairing sidewalk damage caused by city-owned trees, while requiring them to report that damage. The apparent goal is to change who is responsible for such sidewalk repairs.

  • The exemption would cover owners of one-, two- or three-family homes that are at least partly owner-occupied and used only for residential purposes.
  • Those owners would have to report a sidewalk flag damaged by a city-owned tree to the Parks Department or the Department of Transportation. Failing to report would be a violation, with a penalty set under another code provision.
  • The bill would bar the city from directing qualifying owners to repair sidewalk damage caused by a city-owned tree.
  • If the owner reports a sidewalk condition under the bill and the department determines it was not caused by a city-owned tree, the owner would have 90 days to repair it.
  • The Parks Department and the Department of Transportation would have to take steps to implement the law, including making rules. It would take effect 120 days after enactment.

The bill was introduced and referred to committee on June 11, 2026; it is waiting in committee and is not law. The current text of the amended code provisions was not supplied, so the exact change from current law cannot be verified.

What it means for you#

  • Qualifying homeowners: You would not have to repair an abutting sidewalk flag damaged by a city-owned tree, but you would have to report the damage to Parks or Transportation. The text does not require either department to make the repair.
  • Other property owners: The proposed exemption does not cover owners outside the stated one-to-three-family, partly owner-occupied, exclusively residential category.
  • Parks and Transportation: Both departments would have to take implementation steps, including making rules. The bill does not set out a repair process or require either department to repair sidewalks.
  • People with property damage: The text addresses sidewalk flags only. It does not establish a city duty to repair damage to roads or private property.

Money#

No cost information is in the available material.

  • The departments must take steps to implement the law, including making rules, but no cost or staffing estimate is given.
  • The penalty amount for failing to report is not included in the supplied text.

What is unclear#

  • The bill’s title and Council summary describe a Parks Department repair duty, but the operative text creates no such duty.
  • The reporting rule covers damage caused by a city-owned tree, while the 90-day repair rule applies if a department finds a reported condition was not caused by one. The text does not explain how that process would work.
  • The bill does not specify how or when to report damage, how departments would decide what caused it, or how owners could challenge a decision.
  • The amount of the reporting violation’s penalty is not stated in the supplied text.
  • The bill does not explain how the new rules would relate to existing repair or enforcement processes. The current code text was not supplied for comparison.

Case for#

  • A possible argument for the bill is that qualifying homeowners should not have to pay to fix sidewalk damage caused by a city-owned tree.
  • Requiring a report could give the city notice of the damage while the exemption protects those homeowners from being directed to make the repair.

Case against#

  • The bill does not require the city to repair the damage, so the sidewalk could remain unrepaired even when the owner is exempt.
  • A homeowner who fails to report damage would commit a violation, but the supplied text does not state the penalty amount.
  • The repair deadline and reporting process may be difficult to apply: the bill does not explain how an owner reports a condition that the department later finds was not caused by a city-owned tree.