Banning the use of live fish as prizes

Summary#

Introduction 963, sponsored by Council Member Vickie Paladino, would amend New York City’s Administrative Code by adding rules on live fish used as prizes. Its stated goal is to ban that practice. It was introduced and referred to a committee on June 30, 2026, and is still in committee; it is not law.

  • It would prohibit giving live fish as prizes, or offering to exchange them for nominal consideration (a small or token payment), in games, contests and similar promotions.
  • It would also prohibit possessing fish at certain public gatherings on city streets with intent to use them in a prohibited promotion. Each fish could count as a separate violation.
  • Event sponsors with street activity permits would have to prevent violations at their events. The Street Activity Permit Office director would have to notify sponsors; applicants would have to certify they reviewed the notice.
  • The Office of Animal Welfare director would have to post educational materials online about the law, fish disposal, related harms and fish care.
  • The exception allows food service or retail food establishments, or their agents, to offer live fish for human consumption at a reduced rate or for nominal consideration.

What it means for you#

  • People and event sponsors: A person who gives or offers live fish as a prohibited prize could face a civil penalty. A permit-holding event sponsor could also be penalized for allowing a violation at its event.
  • Food businesses: The exception covers live fish offered for human consumption on the stated terms. It does not exempt other prize promotions.
  • Permit applicants: The required certification would start 90 days after the law takes effect. The rest of the law would take effect immediately.
  • General public: The bill requires online education materials, but does not create a fish-care service or an application process for the public.

Money#

No publicly available information on expected costs or penalty revenue.

  • The city would have to produce educational materials and permit notices; the bill gives no cost or staffing estimate.
  • The civil penalty would be $25 per violation for prohibited prize-giving or possession. Event sponsors would face $100 per violation, capped at $500 per day and $2,000 per event. Penalties would be handled by the Office of Administrative Trials and Hearings.

What is unclear#

  • “Nominal consideration” is not defined, and the bill does not set a test for what counts as a similar promotion.
  • The bill does not specify who would investigate violations or how enforcement would begin.
  • The history provided does not name the committee handling the bill.

Case for#

  • The bill appears intended to prevent live fish from being given away and then improperly disposed of. It requires public information about ecological and public-health consequences of disposal.
  • Requiring permit notices and sponsor certifications could make event sponsors aware of the rules before an event.

Case against#

  • One concern is that “fish” is defined broadly to include mollusks, crustaceans and other marine animal life, while “nominal consideration” is undefined.
  • Event sponsors could face penalties for violations by other people at their events. The bill does not explain what steps would be enough to meet their duty to prevent violations.