Summary#
Res. 636, sponsored by Council Member Vickie Paladino, is a nonbinding resolution; it does not change New York City law. It calls on the New York State Legislature to introduce and pass, and the Governor to sign, a law barring state funds and tax benefits for any entity that tests animals, breeds animals for testing, or transports animals for testing. Its stated goal is to protect animals by limiting public support for those activities.
- The requested state law would apply to entities that engage in any of the three listed activities.
- The resolution does not set out rules for defining those activities, exceptions, or how a ban would work.
- The resolution was introduced and referred to a City Council committee on September 10, 2026; the committee’s name is not provided. It is waiting in committee.
What it means for you#
- New York City residents and taxpayers: The resolution itself does not change how state funds or tax benefits are provided, and it creates no new city service or duty.
- Entities involved in animal testing, breeding, or transport: They would not lose funding or tax benefits under this resolution. That could happen only if the state enacted the legislation the Council is requesting.
Money#
No cost estimate or funding amount for the proposed state restriction is provided.
- The resolution cites a state budget recommendation of $6.4 billion in appropriations for the CUNY system in FY 2027. It does not propose changing that amount.
- It does not estimate how much state funding or tax benefits might be affected.
What is unclear#
- The resolution does not include draft state legislation, so the exact wording and scope of any proposed ban are unknown.
- It does not say whether the ban would cover indirect funding, how activities would be defined, or whether there would be exceptions.
- It does not specify enforcement, oversight, timing, or how affected entities could challenge a decision.
Case for#
- The sponsors’ recitals cite the Physicians Committee for Responsible Medicine’s estimate that 10 million to 110 million animals are used in taxpayer-funded research nationwide. The resolution says the wide range reflects gaps in counting.
- The sponsors also cite Rise for Animals’ reports of alleged poor conditions at a New York animal-breeding facility. Those are claims cited by the resolution, not findings established by it.
- The sponsors argue that restricting public funds and tax benefits could prevent taxpayer support from going to animal testing, breeding, and transport.
Case against#
- One concern is the breadth of the requested ban: it would apply to any entity that engages in a listed activity, and the resolution does not say whether the entity’s use of state funds or tax benefits must be connected to that activity.
- The resolution does not describe exceptions or a process for deciding which entities are covered. Without those details, the effect on research institutions and other recipients is unclear.