Limiting nighttime illumination for certain buildings

Summary#

Introduction 0998-2026, sponsored by Council Member Harvey D. Epstein, would add a new chapter to New York City’s Administrative Code. It would restrict nighttime lighting at certain buildings; its stated goal is light-pollution control. It was referred to committee on August 13, 2026, and is not law.

  • From sunset to sunrise, owners or operators of buildings whose main use or dominant occupancy is classified as group B, E, or M under the city Building Code generally could not illuminate the building’s exterior or interior.
  • The bill gives the Landmarks Preservation Commission a limited waiver power for landmark buildings at least 20 stories tall that it finds are significant parts of the city’s skyline. Applicants would have to provide a lighting plan showing light levels and shielding.
  • The Environmental Protection Commissioner could waive or vary the restriction, in coordination with the Police and Buildings commissioners, to the minimum extent needed for safe pedestrian passage in special circumstances.
  • The bill sets exceptions for limited lighting to let people inside exit safely, storefront displays under specified limits, small non-chain stores, and lighting required by law, rule, or the city Zoning Resolution. More restrictive local laws would still apply.
  • The Environmental Protection Commissioner would enforce the restriction and report violations each year. An owner or operator would face a $1,000 civil penalty for each violation.

What it means for you#

  • Owners and operators of covered buildings: If the bill becomes law, they would have to keep the building’s interior and exterior unlit at night unless an exception applies. The text does not explain how “each violation” would be counted.
  • Landmark building owners or operators: Only landmarks at least 20 stories tall could apply for the skyline waiver. The commission would first need rules for deciding what counts as a significant part of the skyline.
  • People inside a building at night: Lighting could remain only to the extent needed for people to exit safely, and only until they have exited.
  • Storefronts: Seasonal displays could be lit from November 1 through January 15, but only until midnight. Other displays could be lit subject to limits on power per window perimeter, fixture location, and light efficiency.
  • Small stores: The restriction would not apply to a store selling goods or services to consumers that occupies under 4,000 square feet of retail or wholesale space (not counting storage) and is not part of a chain.
  • The Department of Environmental Protection: Its commissioner would enforce the rule and publish an annual report naming each violating owner or operator, the building address, and the number of violations.

Money#

No cost estimate is in the available material.

  • The bill assigns enforcement and annual reporting duties to the Environmental Protection Commissioner, but gives no estimate for staffing or other costs.
  • The civil penalty is $1,000 for each violation. The material does not say how many violations are expected or how much penalty revenue might be collected.

What is unclear#

  • The supplied material does not include the current Administrative Code, so it is not possible to verify how the bill compares with existing city lighting rules.
  • The bill does not define “special circumstances,” “safe pedestrian passage,” or how the commissioner would decide on a waiver.
  • The bill does not specify how violations would be investigated, how owners could challenge a penalty, or how “each violation” would be counted.
  • The bill does not give a start date on the calendar. It would take effect 120 days after becoming law.
  • The bill’s history shows only introduction and referral; it is waiting in committee.

Case for#

  • The bill’s title and text frame the measure as a way to control light pollution by limiting nighttime illumination.
  • The rule includes exceptions for safe exits, safe pedestrian passage, required lighting, and certain storefront displays, so it is not an absolute ban on all nighttime lighting.
  • The bill would require public annual reports identifying violations, which could make enforcement visible.

Case against#

  • One concern is that the broad restriction covers both interior and exterior lighting at buildings in three occupancy groups, while the bill does not spell out how many buildings or situations would be affected.
  • The bill leaves important decisions to later rules and commissioner discretion, including which landmarks qualify for a skyline waiver and when safe-passage lighting is needed.
  • Owners and operators could face compliance costs, but the bill provides no estimate or detail on how compliance would be checked.
  • The $1,000 penalty applies to each violation, but the bill does not explain how separate violations would be counted.