Establishing a residence privacy protection program for city elected officials

Summary#

Introduction 1018-2026, sponsored by Council Member Nantasha M. Williams, would amend Title 23 of the New York City Administrative Code to create a residence privacy protection program for city elected officials. Its stated goal is to let participating officials ask city agencies not to disclose their home addresses outside city government. The bill has only been introduced and referred to a committee; it is not law.

  • Each agency privacy officer would administer the program. The Mayor, Comptroller, Public Advocate, Borough Presidents and Council Members could enroll by written request to the Chief Privacy Officer, for the rest of their current term, and could withdraw in writing.
  • Agencies would have to honor a participant’s request not to disclose their address, with exceptions for exigent circumstances, the official’s written approval, a federal or state law or court order, an agency’s good-faith claim of need, or a law-enforcement investigation.
  • For disclosures based on law or court order, an agency’s claimed need, or a law-enforcement investigation, the agency would first need a waiver from its privacy officer. The officer must grant it if the stated legal or other conditions are met.
  • The bill would also limit certain election-law publication requirements, to the extent they cover addresses protected by the program. These include public voter lists and a public book of candidate names and residences.
  • Agencies would have to require covered contractors and subcontractors to follow the rules and create systems to accept and investigate complaints. The bill bars a private right of action to enforce its provisions.

What it means for you#

  • Covered elected officials: You would need to enroll to receive the protection. Participation would last for your term unless you withdraw. Some disclosures could still occur under the listed exceptions; the bill sets notification rules for certain disclosures.
  • City agencies and their contractors: Privacy officers would have to administer the program. Agencies would also have to require relevant contractors and subcontractors to comply, though an agency may assign them some privacy-officer duties.
  • Voters and the public: The bill could limit publication of a participating official’s address in the specified election records. It would not remove all public access to those records or prohibit every address disclosure.
  • Other residents: The bill does not create a general home-address privacy program for the public.

Money#

No cost estimate is in the supplied material.

  • Agencies would have to administer the program, handle waiver requests, provide notices, and accept and investigate complaints. No staffing level or cost is specified.
  • The bill would take effect 120 days after it becomes law. It has not become law.

What is unclear#

  • The supplied material does not include the current Administrative Code, so I could not verify what address protections or related rules already exist.
  • The bill does not define “exigent circumstances” or what counts as an agency’s good-faith need.
  • It does not set out complaint investigation procedures, timelines, or penalties. It expressly rules out a private right of action.
  • The text does not explain how agencies would handle conflicts between the program and other public-record or election-disclosure requirements beyond the specific election-law changes it lists.

Case for#

  • A possible argument for the bill is that elected officials could ask agencies to keep their home addresses from being disclosed outside city government, while still allowing disclosure in specified urgent, legal, or investigative situations.
  • The waiver process could require an agency to explain and justify certain disclosures before they happen.
  • The bill includes complaint investigations and extends key rules to relevant contractors, rather than limiting them to agency staff.

Case against#

  • The bill allows disclosure when an agency asserts in good faith that it needs the address, and requires the privacy officer to grant a waiver if that need is established. The text does not define the standard.
  • Limiting the specified election-record publications could reduce public access to information that election law otherwise requires to be published, though the bill limits this change to disclosures covered by the program.
  • The bill creates duties for agencies but gives no cost estimate, detailed complaint process, or private right of action to enforce the rules.