Collecting and disclosing personal and sensitive information about New York City residents

Summary#

Int. 0708-2026 is a proposed local law, sponsored by Public Advocate Jumaane Williams, that would add a new subchapter to Title 20 of the New York City Administrative Code. It would set privacy duties for certain businesses and other entities that collect information about city residents; its stated subject is collecting and disclosing that information. It is not law: it was referred to a committee on February 24, 2026, and the supplied history does not name the committee.

  • The rules would cover legal entities doing business in New York City that collect information from at least 20,000 city residents.
  • For sensitive information, an entity could not collect or disclose it for a purpose that is not reasonably necessary for and compatible with the purpose disclosed to the resident, unless the resident expressly consents or the collection or disclosure is required by law or court order. Residents could opt out at any time.
  • Covered entities would have to provide a privacy notice and obtain separate, express written consent before using personal or sensitive information to train or develop an artificial intelligence or machine-learning model.
  • On request, an entity would have 90 days to give a resident a list of specific third parties that received their information and to delete their personal or sensitive information, subject to legal or court-order requirements. Withdrawal of consent for further collection or disclosure of sensitive information would take effect within 30 days.
  • The bill would prohibit covered entities from denying goods or services, charging different prices, or otherwise discriminating against residents for exercising these rights. It also provides for civil penalties and enforcement by the Corporation Counsel or its designees.

What it means for you#

  • City residents: If a covered entity collects your information, it would have to explain what categories it collects, why, how long it keeps them, and the categories of recipients. You could request the specific third parties that received your information, request deletion, and withdraw consent for future collection or disclosure of sensitive information.
  • Residents using covered services: The entity could not deny you goods or services, charge you a different price, or otherwise discriminate against you for exercising the bill’s rights.
  • Businesses and other covered entities: The threshold is 20,000 or more city residents. “Personal information” includes identifiers such as names, addresses, email addresses and IP addresses. Sensitive information includes genetic or biometric information, gender identity, precise geolocation, government-ID images and certain device identifiers. Affiliates and agents would have to follow the same standards and privacy policies as the collecting entity.
  • Exceptions: The requirements would not apply to government entities or contractors acting for them, certain federally regulated information and entities, or personal data collected, used or disclosed in covered clinical research.
  • Complaint handling: The Department of Information Technology and Telecommunications, working with relevant agencies, would have to create an online complaint portal and report complaint numbers, types and outcomes to the Council Speaker and Mayor each year by October 1.
  • Timing: The law would start 180 days after it becomes law. Where the new rules cannot be applied consistently with existing contracts, they would apply only to contracts entered into or renewed after the start date.

Money#

No publicly available information on the bill’s public cost or expected business compliance costs.

  • The bill would require the department to build and maintain a complaint portal and submit annual reports, but provides no cost or staffing estimate.
  • Civil penalties would be up to $500 for a first violation and each additional violation on the same day; later violations within a 12-month period would carry penalties of $500 to $1,500 each. Each failure to give the required AI-use notice would be a separate violation.

What is unclear#

  • The supplied history does not name the committee considering the bill, and does not show a hearing or vote.
  • The bill does not set a process for investigating complaints, deciding violations, or notifying residents of outcomes.
  • It does not explain how the 20,000-resident threshold would be counted or measured.
  • The bill does not specify how its duties would interact with privacy rules or programs beyond the listed exceptions.

Case for#

  • A possible argument for the bill is that residents would get clearer information about what covered entities collect, why they collect it, and with whom they share it.
  • Separate written consent for using personal or sensitive information to develop AI models could give residents a distinct choice about that use.
  • Deletion and withdrawal rights, a ban on discrimination for exercising those rights, and penalties could make the stated protections more enforceable.

Case against#

  • One concern is that “personal information” is defined broadly, while the bill does not explain how covered entities would determine whether they have reached the 20,000-resident threshold.
  • The bill sets duties and penalties but leaves complaint investigations and violation decisions largely unspecified.
  • The contract transition rule could delay the rules for some existing arrangements until contracts are renewed or replaced.