The relocation of motor vehicles due to temporary parking restrictions

Summary#

Introduction 1036-2026, sponsored by Council Member Simcha Felder, would amend New York City’s Administrative Code. It is waiting in committee and is not law. Its stated goal is to set rules for where vehicles may be moved when parking restrictions are temporary.

  • The Police Department, licensed tow operators and other city entities could not relocate a vehicle removed for temporary parking restrictions to a parking meter or a place where parking, stopping or standing is prohibited, unless public safety requires it.
  • Licensed tow operators who violate that rule would face fines: $500 for a first violation, $1,000 for a second within 12 months of the first, and $1,000 for each additional violation within 24 months of the first. An operator directed by a government entity to make an otherwise authorized relocation would not face these fines.
  • A vehicle owner could use an affirmative defense (a legal reason to contest a ticket) if the vehicle was moved to the ticketed location before the violation and the notice covers the specified period: from the relocation until 11 p.m. on the first full business day after the relocation date.
  • Owners could request a written towing record from the relevant police precinct within 45 days of the towing.
  • If enacted, the local law would take effect 120 days after it becomes law.

What it means for you#

  • Vehicle owners: If your vehicle is ticketed after being moved to a prohibited spot during a temporary parking restriction, you could raise the bill’s affirmative defense. You would need a precinct record or other evidence accepted by the hearing officer. This would not automatically cancel the ticket.
  • Vehicle owners: You could request the towing record from the relevant precinct within 45 days. The bill says it must include information already required under another part of the Administrative Code; that provision was not supplied for comparison.
  • Tow operators and city entities: The relocation restriction would apply to them. The stated fines apply to licensed tow operators, with the government-direction exception described above.

Money#

No cost information is in the available material.

  • The bill sets fines for licensed tow operators, but gives no estimate of fine revenue, staffing needs or enforcement costs.

What is unclear#

  • The bill does not say who would enforce the relocation prohibition or how violations would be identified and decided.
  • It does not explain how the Police Department or other city entities would choose a lawful relocation location when nearby options are restricted.
  • The bill does not define “temporary parking restrictions.”
  • The existing requirements in Administrative Code section 20-528(a), which the new towing record must include, were not supplied, so the full contents of that record cannot be confirmed here.

Case for#

  • The bill’s design could prevent a vehicle from being moved into a spot where it is immediately at risk of a ticket.
  • The ticket defense and access to a towing record could help owners show that a vehicle was moved there, rather than parked there by the owner.
  • Fines could give licensed tow operators a reason to follow the relocation rule.

Case against#

  • The bill does not set out how agencies or tow operators should find lawful relocation spots, which could make the rule difficult to apply when many nearby locations are restricted.
  • The ticket defense is limited to a specific time window and requires evidence accepted by the hearing officer; owners may still have to take steps to contest a ticket.
  • The government-direction exception removes the stated fines in some cases, but the bill does not explain how responsibility would be handled when an agency directs a relocation that violates the rule.