Requirements for the removal of public litter baskets by the department of sanitation

Summary#

Introduction 1041-2026, sponsored by Council Member Ty Hankerson, would amend New York City’s Administrative Code to set rules for the Department of Sanitation (DSNY) when removing public litter baskets. Its apparent goal is to limit one reason for removal and require notice, public input, and reporting. It has been laid over in the Sanitation and Solid Waste Management Committee and is not law.

  • DSNY could not remove a public litter basket solely because someone put household or commercial refuse, or liquid waste, in it illegally.
  • Before removing a basket, DSNY would have to email notice to the affected Council Member and community board. The notice must give the location, reasons, and how to comment.
  • The Council Member and community board could comment within 10 business days after receiving notice. DSNY would have to review and consider comments it receives before removing the basket.
  • DSNY would have to publish and submit quarterly reports listing basket numbers and locations, removals and reasons, and littering complaint counts for affected community districts before and after removals.

What it means for you#

  • Residents: The bill does not directly change rules for people using litter baskets. It would restrict one sole ground for DSNY removal and make information about baskets and removals public.
  • Council Members and community boards: They would receive notice and could send recommendations or comments. The bill does not require DSNY to follow them.
  • DSNY: The department would have to give notice before any removal, consider comments received, and meet the reporting requirements. The bill does not expressly require it to wait the full 10 business days before removing a basket.

Money#

No cost information is in the available material.

  • The bill would require DSNY to provide notices and prepare, submit, and publish quarterly reports, but it gives no staffing or cost estimate.

What is unclear#

  • The bill does not specify how much time DSNY must allow before removing a basket after giving notice; it sets a 10-business-day period for comments but does not expressly make that a waiting period.
  • It does not say what DSNY must do if it receives comments, beyond reviewing and considering them.
  • It does not specify how littering complaints are counted or what “littering complaints” includes.
  • The bill would take effect 120 days after it becomes law. Whether it becomes law is uncertain.

Case for#

  • The bill would prevent illegal dumping from being the sole reason to remove a public litter basket, while still allowing removal for other reasons.
  • Notice, an opportunity to comment, and public reports could give local representatives and community boards information about proposed and completed removals.
  • Complaint counts before and after removals could help show how removals relate to littering complaints in the area, though the bill does not require a particular response to those counts.

Case against#

  • One concern is that notice and comment could add work or delay removals; the bill does not set a clear minimum time for DSNY to act.
  • DSNY must consider comments but need not follow them, so the bill does not guarantee local input changes a removal decision.
  • The reporting workload could require staff time, but the bill gives no cost estimate or details on how DSNY would collect the information.