Prohibiting candidates from appearing in certain government-funded third-party communications during an election campaign

Summary#

Introduction 1075-2026, sponsored by Council Member David M. Carr, would amend the New York City Charter. It would bar certain public servants who are candidates, and their spouses, from appearing in or taking part in government-funded third-party communications during the 90 days before an election. The stated goal is to limit candidates’ participation in such communications during an election campaign.

  • The bill defines a “third-party public communication” as a published communication—including online content—whose author is not a public servant or agency, or is not clearly identified as one.
  • The restriction would apply when government funds or resources pay for any part of the communication and it is published less than 90 days before a primary or general election for an office the person is seeking.
  • The bill also keeps a separate restriction on government-funded mass mailings, including an exception for one mailing within 21 days after adoption of the executive budget. The available materials do not show how much of this rule is new.
  • The bill is in committee, not law. It had a hearing and was laid over on September 22, 2026, then referred to committee on September 24.

What it means for you#

  • Public servants who are candidates, and their spouses: If enacted, they could not appear in or otherwise participate in covered communications during the 90-day period. The bill does not prohibit a third party from publishing a communication; it restricts the candidate’s or spouse’s participation.
  • Other residents and organizations: The bill does not directly change your rights or require you to apply for anything. It does not set out rules for how a communication would be reviewed or challenged.
  • City government: The text does not name an agency to administer or enforce the new restriction.

Money#

No publicly available information.

  • The bill does not specify spending, staffing, fees, or fines.

What is unclear#

  • “Not clearly identified” is not defined, and the bill does not explain how to decide whether a candidate has “participated” in a communication.
  • The available materials do not include the current full text of the Charter provision, so the existing law and the exact changes to the mass-mailing rule could not be fully verified.
  • The bill does not set out enforcement, exceptions, or a process for resolving disputes.

Case for#

  • The bill appears intended to limit candidates’ involvement in communications funded in whole or in part with government resources close to an election.
  • A possible argument for the approach is that a clear 90-day period could reduce candidates’ participation in publicly funded communications during that campaign period.

Case against#

  • One concern is that “not clearly identified” and “participate” are undefined, leaving uncertainty about which communications and actions are covered.
  • The bill does not specify who would enforce the restriction or how candidates and others could get a decision about whether a communication is covered.