Limiting the circumstances in which participating candidates and their principal committees must repay public matching funds to the campaign finance board

Summary#

Int. 0904-2026 is a proposed local law that would amend New York City’s Administrative Code rules on repaying public campaign matching funds. Its goal is to limit when participating candidates and their principal committees must repay those funds; the Council’s prime sponsor is Frank Morano. The bill was introduced on May 14, 2026, and is waiting in committee, so it is not law.

  • If the Campaign Finance Board (CFB) finds that a committee received more public funds than it was eligible for, the bill would require repayment only if the candidate or committee committed fraud to obtain the excess.
  • For funds used for purposes other than qualified campaign expenditures, repayment would be required only if that use was known, or reasonably knowable, to the candidate or committee.
  • The bill would limit when a candidate can be personally liable for such spending. In specified cases involving incomplete or missing documentation, it bars or allows personal liability under stated conditions.
  • If a candidate challenges a repayment decision in court under Article 78, the CFB would have to pause enforcement until the court issues a judgment.
  • The text also addresses repayment in other situations, including failure to actively campaign. The supplied materials do not show how much of that wording would change current law.

What it means for you#

  • Participating candidates and their committees: The bill would add fraud or knowledge-related conditions to certain repayment claims. It would not remove every repayment obligation: other rules in the bill cover excess campaign funds, failure to actively campaign, and disqualification for fraud in obtaining a place on the ballot.
  • Candidates who challenge a repayment decision: If a candidate brings the specified court case, enforcement of the repayment claim would be stayed while the case is before the court. The text does not extend this stay to a challenge brought only by a committee.
  • Other New Yorkers: The bill does not directly change voter eligibility, taxes, or public matching-fund amounts.

Money#

No cost estimate is available in the supplied material.

  • The bill could affect how much public matching money the CFB recovers from candidates and committees. The materials do not estimate the amount.
  • The bill does not set a new appropriation, fee, or fine.
  • The CFB would have to stay enforcement in the specified court cases; the materials give no estimate of any staffing or administrative cost.

What is unclear#

  • The bill does not define “fraudulent acts,” “reasonably knowable,” or “adequate controls.”
  • The supplied materials do not include the current text of the amended Administrative Code section, so the exact change to every provision cannot be independently checked.
  • The bill does not explain how the CFB should decide whether conduct was reasonably knowable or what evidence is enough to show fraud.
  • The text sets an effective date of 120 days after the local law becomes law, but passage and enactment are uncertain because the bill is still in committee.

Case for#

  • The bill’s stated aim is to limit repayment claims. Requiring fraud for repayment of excess payments could protect candidates and committees from having to repay money because of an overpayment alone.
  • Requiring that improper spending was known or reasonably knowable could make repayment depend on what the candidate or committee could have known, rather than on the spending alone.
  • A required pause in enforcement during the specified court challenge could prevent collection before the court rules.

Case against#

  • The bill does not define key tests such as “reasonably knowable.” That could leave candidates and the CFB uncertain about when repayment is required.
  • Requiring proof of fraud or knowledge could make it harder for the CFB to recover public funds, even when it determines that a committee received excess money or used funds for unqualified expenses.
  • The required enforcement stay could delay recovery while a court case is pending; the materials do not estimate how often this might happen.