Reporting on third-party public communications

Summary#

Introduction 1076-2026, sponsored by Council Member David M. Carr, would amend the New York City Charter. Its stated aim, reflected in its title, is reporting on third-party public communications.

  • A public servant who uses or authorizes city funds or resources for a covered communication would have to ensure information about it is reported to the Department of Records and Information Services (DORIS).
  • The information must include the author and their usernames and platforms, the subject, any vendor that hired the author, and a description of the city funds or resources used, including the total amount paid if any.
  • DORIS would have to report the information to the Mayor and Council Speaker and post it on the city’s Open Data portal at least quarterly in an election year and at least twice a year otherwise.
  • The bill defines a covered communication broadly as any published communication whose author is not a public servant or city agency, or is not clearly identified as one. It is not limited to websites or social media.
  • The text says reports must be made “no less than 60 days after” the use or authorization. This means at least 60 days must pass; it does not set a latest date for reporting.

The bill is listed as referred to the Committee on Governmental Operations, State & Federal Legislation. The history also records a hearing and that the committee laid it over. It is not law.

What it means for you#

  • Public servants: Officials and city employees, including community board members and paid advisory committee members, would have to ensure reports are made when they use or authorize city funds or resources for a covered communication. Unpaid advisory committee members are excluded from the bill’s definition of “public servant.”
  • People and organizations authoring communications: The report could disclose their names, usernames, platforms, and the communication’s subject. If a vendor hired the author, the vendor’s name would also be reported.
  • General public: DORIS would publish the reported information on the city’s Open Data portal. The bill does not create a process for people to apply for a review or appeal a reporting decision.

Money#

No cost estimate is available in the supplied material.

  • The bill requires reporting and public posting, but does not state a staffing level, budget, or funding source.
  • Reports must include the total amount of city funds paid for a communication, if any. This is a disclosure requirement, not a new fee or tax.

What is unclear#

  • The text sets no latest reporting date: “no less than 60 days after” requires a wait of at least 60 days but does not say when the report must be filed by.
  • “Governmental funds or resources” and “published communication” are not defined.
  • The bill does not explain how public servants would report information, who would check it, or how DORIS would handle missing or disputed information.
  • It is unclear how the reporting duty would work when more than one public servant uses or authorizes resources for a communication.

Case for#

  • The bill’s reporting and public-posting requirements could give the public information about communications made using city funds or resources, including who authored them and what they cost.
  • Requiring DORIS to publish the information on a regular schedule would make the reports available in one place.

Case against#

  • One concern is that the reporting deadline has no stated end point, so reports could be delayed indefinitely.
  • The bill covers any published communication meeting its broad definition, while leaving key terms such as “governmental resources” undefined. This could make it unclear which communications must be reported.
  • The bill creates duties for public servants and DORIS but gives no cost estimate, staffing plan, or reporting and checking procedures.